FBI figures show Santa Clarita had the eighth-lowest number of reported crimes in the nation in 2002 among cities with populations over 100,000.
FBI figures would also show that Santa Clarita had the absolute lowest number of reported crimes among cities with populations over 150,000 — if only the FBI reported the numbers that way.
On Thursday the city of Santa Clarita sent a letter to FBI Director Robert S. Mueller, asking him to change the way the bureau reports crime statistics.
“We are writing to respectfully request that the FBI consider adding another category to its safe city list,” the city’s letter said. “We would like for you to add ‘cities with a population of 150,000 or more.’”
Mayor Cameron Smyth said he authorized his signature on the letter because “over the past several years, our ranking has continued to drop, but that hasn’t necessarily been due to an increase in our crime rate. (The new category) would provide a more equitable, apples-to-apples comparison to cities of more similar size.”
FBI spokeswoman Laura Bosley said the bureau might consider adding the category “if there were a legitimate reason to do so.”
But, she noted, “we don’t rank cities whatsoever. The media (do), based on the numbers. The rankings ignore the uniqueness of each locale (and) create a misleading perception.”
The FBI does not publish crime rates for cities — the number of crimes per capita. Instead, the FBI releases the raw number of serious crimes — murders, forcible rapes, robberies, aggravated assaults, burglaries, larceny, auto thefts and arson — as reported each year by local police agencies in cities with populations over 100,000.
The 1990 U.S. Census showed Santa Clarita had a population only slightly over the threshold — 110,690. Santa Clarita had a correspondingly low number of reported crimes, typically placing No. 3 or 4 on the list of cities over 100,000.
As the city’s population grew to 162,900 as of Jan. 1, 2003, Santa Clarita moved to No. 8 on the list — but only because more cities made the list for the first time as they passed the 100,000-population mark.
Santa Clarita’s actual crime rate, meanwhile — crimes per capita — remained fifth lowest in the nation among cities with more than 100,000 residents, and lowest among cities over 133,000 population, according to unofficial calculations by The Signal using the FBI crime list and Census Bureau population estimates.
“We take a lot of pride in the crime rate remaining low despite the increase in population,” city spokeswoman Gail Ortiz said. “We want to be recognized for being a safe city.
“We’re not asking them to report crime rates,” she said. “All we’re asking is for them to add a category to what they already do.”
Michael Haviland, the city’s economic development director, said official bragging rights to No. 1 status among cities with 150,000-plus residents could help spur economic activity.
“It is important that we can create a positive image and identity for our community,” he said. “It needs to be based on fact, and these (numbers) are factual. It’s a strong marketing story for economic development.”
Ortiz acknowledged the FBI “may not get around to our request” anytime soon.
“They’re probably busy catching criminals and that sort of thing, but it doesn’t hurt to ask. We hope they take it as seriously as we do.”
