If it was meant to be a partisan reminder to blame California’s budget fiasco on the Davis administration’s bungling two years ago of the energy crisis, it worked — but it couldn’t have come at a worse time.
On Wednesday the GOP-controlled Federal Energy Regulatory Commission voted to deny the state’s request to void $12 billion in long-term energy contracts.
The state was looking for a way out of the pacts it signed at the height of the power crunch, arguing it had been forced to negotiate them in an inflated market where prices had been driven up by fraud committed by Enron and other shady energy traders.
But the two Republicans on the 3-member FERC panel said it was sour grapes for the state and spurned California’s plea because, they said, the state had been a willing partner in the deals and had employed savvy negotiators.
From a moral standpoint it’s difficult to argue the majority opinion. The state government decided to enter long-term agreements with reputable energy providers because it figured it could get a better deal than it would get if it rode out the short-term spot market. The state gambled and lost, and the FERC decided that now, it’s just too bad. It would be punitive to the reputable firms if the feds stepped in today and voided contracts that were negotiated in good faith.
But from a practical standpoint, the decision is devastating for millions of taxpaying Californians who are left holding the bag. They’ll pay through higher taxes, or reduced government services, or both, depending on how the Legislature ultimately decides to balance the scales that were tipped when it made what turned out to be a lousy bargain two years ago.
If there’s any sunshine on the horizon, it’s that the Golden State can expect to receive about $3 billion of the $9 billion it’s seeking to offset short-term contract rip-offs by disreputable firms like Enron.
And separately, the FERC slapped that dead horse by revoking Enron’s authority to operate on the open market. It also ordered administrative trials for several dozen other power brokers that could be forced to return profits if they’re found to have engaged in price manipulation.
Gov. Gray Davis said the state would appeal the FERC’s decision to uphold the long-term contracts.
“By touting their punishment of Enron, they seek to hide the fact that they still have not punished any other of the dozens of generators who ripped off California,” Davis said. “We will not let them get away with that.”
The truth is, the FERC probably will get away with that. Sure, the matter could and no doubt will end up in court. But long before there’s any judicial ruling, taxpayers will have felt the sting and the governor will most likely be focusing all of his attention on a recall fight.
