Unification. For many recent San Fernando Valley transplants, the word no doubt triggers unwelcome memories of Los Angeles and its behemoth school district.
The very concept seems an affront to the notion of local control and the idea, where schools are concerned, that decisions are best made by the people who are most directly affected, and not by faraway bureaucrats.
But the Santa Clarita Valley isn’t Los Angeles, and the problems don’t directly translate. In fact, our schools are so systemically fractured that some think we should consider unification as a means of achieving the benefits of economies of scale.
If less money can be wasted on bureaucratic redundancy, the theory goes, there could be more money to be spent in the classroom.
High school board member Dennis King made the point this week in a discussion of a bus-storage contract with the Newhall School District.
The two districts are at odds over a deal struck more than a decade ago that specified how much the elementary district would pay to the high school district to store its buses at the high school district’s facility.
The Newhall district has staff to run its bus fleet, and the Hart district has staff to run its bus fleet (or at least it did, when its buses were servicing students throughout the valley). If there were one school district there would be one “bus office” with one set of administrative costs, rather than two.
Or actually more, since there’s more than one elementary district in the valley that operates buses.
Despite its relatively small size in comparison to a mammoth area like Los Angeles, the Santa Clarita Valley has one school district that oversees the valley’s junior and senior high schools, and four separate school districts to operate the elementary schools on the different sides of the valley.
Each of the five districts is a separate entity with its own school board, its own district offices, and its own administrative staff.
Of course, buses aren’t the only area where systems are duplicated. There are five sets of staff to deal with the state and federal governments, five sets of staff to administer special programs, five sets of staff to negotiate deals with teachers unions, and on and on.
How did that happen in such a small place? The answer goes way back to the late 1800s and early 1900s when the elementary schools, which ran through grade eight, were few and far between. Soledad Canyon was a long way from Newhall, which was a long way from Castaic, for a kid on a horse. So it was appropriate for the far-flung schools to be operated by their own parents in their own districts.
It took decades before there was a sufficient population to warrant a high school. But local residents wanted one, because the daily bus ride to San Fernando High School was too arduous. Finally, in the 1940s, the boards of the then-existing five elementary districts were able to get a bond measure on the ballot to build a high school.
Who would run it? Well, everyone, since it was to serve the whole valley. Representatives of the five school boards created a separate school district to run the new “junior and senior high school,” Hart, with a separate school board to represent the residents of all five elementary districts.
Looking back, the setup made sense. But does it serve current needs now that the Santa Clarita Valley is a much “closer” place?
Lest there be any mistake, we’re not advocating unification today. We’re merely asking, is the current system the best way to serve the children of the Santa Clarita Valley?
Whether you agree or disagree with Dennis King, his comments provoke a valid question, and maybe we’d benefit from some healthy debate.
