ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Blue Barrel and the city: All in and all done!

Blue Barrel bought the City Council.

That is, at last weekend’s Santa Clarita Valley Boys and Girls Club auction, Blue Barrel was the winning bidder on a dinner to be served by the five members of the City Council.

The $4,000 winning donation was made at a most interesting time: Three days before a scheduled council vote on whether to narrow down the field of potential trash haulers from six applicants to three, as the city tries to determine who will get the next multi-multi-multi-million-dollar contract to haul your trash.

There is no better charity in town than the Boys and Girls Club. And I’m glad to see that Blue Barrel, the local subsidiary of Waste Management Inc., is supporting such a worthy organization.

Yet there’s a certain brash lack of couth in that particular purchase. Three days before a big vote on their proposed public service contract, and they’re paying $4,000 to have the people who will make the decision serve them dinner.

Of course, this is Santa Clarita, where the local movers and shakers see such a thing happen and say, “Oh, how deliciously ironic and cute that is!”

Sometimes I wonder about this town.

Anyway. The vote Tuesday night surely was not affected by the auction, and no one else around here seems concerned about how things might appear. So there you go.

The vote on Tuesday was 5-0 in favor of the staff recommendation, which was to essentially eliminate three haulers from contention and continue negotiations with (surprise!) Blue Barrel, Burrtec (based in Fontana) and Consolidated (the hauler that serves the 15 percent of Santa Clarita that isn’t served by Blue Barrel under the existing contract).

I expected council members Frank Ferry and Marsha McLean to go along with it because of their apparently strong allegiance to Waste Management (which, for McLean, evidently outweighs her allegiance to preserving Elsmere Canyon, since one of the quickly dismissed haulers had offered the city the opportunity to acquire a key piece of Elsmere property as an enticement...)

I had, however, expected better from the other three council members — Cameron Smyth, Bob Kellar and Laurene Weste. I thought they would say, “Enough!” and do more to ensure the haulers were competing on a level playing field.

Regrettably, they did not.

Even Weste, who spoke out against the staff recommendation and is certainly no toady for Waste Management, went along with it. That way, you see, we get a nice, tidy, non-offensive 5-0 vote.

I’m not sure when this happened, but more and more often over the past couple of years it seems council members vote in favor of things they really oppose, all for the sake of getting a 5-0 vote and presenting a “unified front.” I’d rather see our leaders lead, even if it means being on the wrong end of a 4-1 vote. It’s enough to make me miss former Councilwoman Jill Klajic; I rarely agreed with her — and she and I had our share of explosive disputes — but if she disagreed with something, she’d cast that lone dissenting vote.

Wrong as she often was, I respect that.

No such thing happened Tuesday; Smyth said he went along with the recommendation because he was on the committee that chose the consultant (evidently no other factors mattered), and Weste voted in favor of it despite saying the city would be better served if it spent the time to make sure the proposals were compared on an apples-to-apples basis.

How about a little courage to go with those convictions?

As I wrote in this space last week — and as Weste pointed out before joining the 5-0 vote — the staff recommendation was based on faulty math and a set of proposals that cannot be compared side-by-side based on price alone. That is simply due to the fact that Blue Barrel was the only one of the six haulers that balked at a very key portion of the city’s request for proposals.

Each hauler listed “exceptions” to the RFP, which are points upon which they wish to negotiate if they proceed further.

Most of those exceptions were rather pedestrian, and do not appear to materially impact the haulers’ prices. But Blue Barrel’s biggest exception indicated the hauler does not believe the city’s waste diversion goals are attainable. Specifically, Blue Barrel said the goals are “unworkable and may even be impossible to meet.”

In other words, five haulers submitted prices to haul your trash and meet the diversion goals. One did not.

Yet, that hauler is retained as one of the final three, and city officials say it was simply a matter of math: Blue Barrel’s proposed prices are the lowest.

Well, of COURSE they are! After all, if you’re not worried about those pesky diversion goals, you can undercut the competition.

City officials say their hands were tied because the recommendation was based on a mathematical formula established before the proposals were submitted. Cue the church lady: “Isn’t that convenient...”

Nevermind the fact that the RFP stated, clearly (page 26), that price was only one of several key factors: “The proposal will be objectively evaluated based on criteria that may include, but (are) not limited to, the following factors WITHOUT PREFERENCE OF ONE FACTOR OVER ANOTHER (emphasis added)...”

The RFP then lists these items: Proposer’s qualifications, technical qualifications, exceptions to the terms and conditions, financial resources, and costs.

Nevermind also the fact that the RFP stated, specifically (page 3), that “the city discourages, and may disqualify, proposals that substantially deviate from the RFP.”

Cripes. If saying the waste diversion goals are “unworkable” doesn’t qualify as a “substantial” deviation, what does? I guess we’re lucky they at least agreed to pick up the trash.

What we ended up with was a staff recommendation based too heavily (almost exclusively) on dollar amounts, and not at all on qualitative analysis. It smelled funny. Even giving everyone the benefit of the doubt, at best, the process was flawed to the point of absurdity.

But here is my sincere hope:

I want Blue Barrel and the city to make me look bad.

My theory is as follows, and I want to be proven wrong. Call it a challenge.

It appears Blue Barrel came in with a lowball bid it knew was unrealistic, a rate that cannot possibly work if the hauler is to do the things it would need to do to meet the diversion goals.

But that didn’t matter in the initial stages; as my theory goes, all they really wanted to do was scout and eliminate some of the competition, make the initial cut. Hence, their price was based on the assertion that the diversion goals are “unworkable,” and they could leave the real price-setting and negotiating for later.

And now, they know what everyone else’s price is. All they have to do is negotiate their “real” price, which will be marginally lower than the competition’s, and agree to meet the diversion goals.

If this proves true, at least it will mean taxpayers get a much better deal than they get now (we’re getting ripped off now...). The process, though, has proven flawed, the playing field tilted sharply.

Prove me wrong. I’d love that.

Whatever happens, I’m sure it will pass on a “unified” 5-0 vote. Regardless, if Blue Barrel agrees to stick to the rates in its proposal, and agrees to meet the diversion goals, and further agrees to pay the $10,000-per-day fine if it doesn’t meet the state’s diversion requirements, then we ought to sign them up and celebrate.

The City Council can serve dinner.

Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.

← Back to 2003

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:2804.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,278 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [managing editor]
  • text:valley_names [3 distinct/8 mentions: Santa Clarita, City Council, Elsmere]
  • text:valley_elected_official “Cameron Smyth”, “Smyth”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0