The irony of Councilman Frank Ferry purporting to stick up for the “little guy” is inescapable.
For you see, when it comes to fund-raising at the local level in Santa Clarita Valley politics, Ferry is about the biggest big guy around. In his last campaign, he hauled in more than $57,000 in campaign contributions — despite local fund-raising limits that he now argues are too restrictive.
So you’ll forgive us for looking askance at Ferry when he proposes that those local limits be quadrupled, supposedly in the name of helping the “little guy” compete on a more equal footing with the fund-raising heavyweights like himself.
Ferry and his fellow council members — four others who, we’re sure, think it may be easier for them as incumbents to raise money without those pesky limitations — voted unanimously on Tuesday to take the first step toward hiking the limit from its present $250, per person, per election cycle, to $1,000 per person, per election cycle.
The council actually just directed the staff to come back with an amendment to the current campaign ordinance, and that amendment itself would require the council’s approval.
But you can see where this is going.
There are other potential modifications to the ordinance that would be included in Ferry’s proposal — and the details of those modifications can be reasonably argued among reasonable people. For example, some might debate that an increase in the amount that can be donated without the donor’s name being listed publicly is a fair modification that allows people who aren’t political heavy hitters to make a modest donation without public scrutiny. Other equally reasonable people might argue that, since it’s a public election, all donations should be public.
Further, there can always be made interesting constitutional arguments about campaign contribution limits, particularly if one considers such donations a form of “speech” that should be protected under the First Amendment.
However, if we presume for now that reasonable limitations can and should exist, the question is, where is the threshold of reasonableness?
The centerpiece of Ferry’s proposal is to jump from a $250 limit to a $1,000 limit. That’s no modest hike.
There is talk of making Santa Clarita’s limits “consistent” with the limits for state offices. However, Santa Clarita is under absolutely no obligation to do so. Therefore, the question should be decided on its own merits as they directly apply to Santa Clarita and its politics.
As Ferry’s argument goes, the city’s campaign contribution ordinance, put into effect in 1992, was designed for a time when a winning council campaign in Santa Clarita might cost $6,000 to $10,000.
As evidenced by Ferry’s own campaign from last year, that no longer is the case.
The councilman contends that we can’t expect candidates — particularly grass-roots candidates without support of the “establishment” — to compete while having to solicit contributions at $250 a pop.
With all due respect to Councilman Ferry, we believe his logic is flawed.
Certainly, the “little guy” will then be able to hit up his friends, family and neighbors not for $250 apiece, but for $1,000 apiece.
But likewise, the “big guy” — a capable fund-raiser like Ferry, or one of his council colleagues — would be able to ask his or her own friends, family, neighbors and moneyed local interests for $1,000 apiece.
Think about that.
Who is more likely to know a large number of people willing to part with $1,000 to donate to a Santa Clarita City Council campaign?
The little guy?
Or, the big guy?
Further, as we saw in last year’s election, well-heeled donors would often recruit family members to make donations of their own — thus, a family of four adults might collectively account for $1,000. Under Ferry’s plan, that same family could chip in $4,000.
It seems a continued escalation of campaign spending would be likely, and the little guy will be further behind in the dust than he already is.
Even if one were to accept Ferry’s overall logic — and we don’t — it seems this is an area in which some sort of compromise is in order. Perhaps it’s fair to say $250, established a decade ago, is no longer a reasonable ceiling. However, we sincerely doubt that a quadrupling of the limit is necessary; a smaller bite would appear less gluttonous.
Especially if, as we’re being told, the motive is to look out for the “little guy” — a claim that is dubious at best when made by the local fund-raising giant.
