Over the years, the Santa Clarita City Council has earned a reputation for yielding to whoever happens to bring the biggest show of citizen force to a council meeting.
On a variety of issues in the past decade and a half, our city’s decisions have been swayed by sometimes-angry mobs of adults, children, parents, environmentalists and, that well-known suburban creature, the NIMBY, which derives its name from the acronym, Not In My Back Yard.
Sometimes those decisions have been otherwise well-reasoned and correct. Sometimes, they have simply allowed the council to feel good about doing what “the community” wanted, even if the decision was the wrong one.
It’s strange, the definition of “the community.” To some politicians I’ve known locally over the years, that phrase has meant, “My immediate friends and supporters.”
To others, it has meant, “The movers and shakers, and the people who give money to my political campaigns.”
And to others, “the community” has simply been whatever vocal minority happens to show up at a particular City Council meeting.
I have long advocated that our city leaders should make the best decisions for the entire community, not just whatever group makes the most noise at City Hall on a given issue.
Those five people represent every one of us, and, as Councilman Cameron Smyth so eloquently put it during a recent controversial decision, that includes everyone in this city, not just those who attend City Council meetings.
It even includes those who don’t vote, don’t participate in local charities and don’t go to chamber of commerce mixers. The council members represent us all.
This applies to everything that goes before the City Council, including the hot item on the council agenda for July 8, the proposed expansion of the Valencia Auto Center.
For the record, I am neutral on this project — quite simply due to the fact that I don’t know enough to reconcile its positives versus the alleged negatives.
I can see its up sides — increased sales tax revenue, solidifying the local auto mall within the city without allowing it to stray over to the county territory along the freeway, preserving the William S. Hart PONY Complex. Those are all legitimate and important benefits of this project that, I’m sure, will — and should — weigh heavily in the council’s decision.
But those things are obvious.
What’s not obvious, to me at least, is the question of whether the project could be better than it is: Can the design be tweaked in any way to better manage traffic and parking or make it more visually appealing? Can the grading plan be revised to make it more palatable to opponents? Can the dirt-moving schedule be revised to make it less of an imposition on the community at large?
Are the concerns raised by local environmentalists valid? Will it have impacts on the Santa Clara River and/or endangered species that can’t be mitigated? Personally, I think our environmental community objects to a lot of things just for the sake of objecting, especially if the valley’s largest developer — Newhall Land — is involved, as it is in this project, despite the fact that Newhall Land’s developments include many of the nicest parts of town.
I really, truly, don’t know whether those environmental issues are valid or just another anti-growth, anti-business smokescreen.
The benefits, like I said, are obvious, but I’m not in a position right now to say whether the benefits outweigh the costs.
So on this one, I’m Switzerland. I will neither endorse it nor oppose it.
That’s why I’m simply making one request, as a citizen, of my City Council:
Make this decision on the merits of the case, not by checking the wind direction in council chambers on July 8. Don’t simply be swayed by who favors the project and who opposes it.
The “who favors it” category is an influential group: Local movers and shakers. Business leaders. Friends and financial supporters of City Council members. And, perhaps most compelling, the young boys and girls who play at the Hart PONY Baseball and Softball complex.
The Hart PONY program is one of the biggest assets this community has. It provides a valuable service to Santa Claritans, offering important sports and recreational opportunities to children. As part of this auto mall expansion project, the PONY organization would get to keep its complex along Valencia Boulevard, where the property has been provided for years by Newhall Land, which owns the site.
Obviously, those in the PONY organization — kids and parents alike — will favor this project because of its direct benefit to their program. I don’t blame them one bit. It is a fabulous opportunity for the organization.
For the City Council, the potential benefit of keeping Hart PONY right where it is should be a major factor, but it should not be the only factor.
Newhall Land and other advocates of the project have chosen their allies well: How difficult would it be to look a bunch of kids in the eye at a council meeting and vote against them? It is an extremely astute strategy. I applaud the thinking that has gone into that. It’s smart, Machiavellian politicking.
But our council must achieve the right balance of making the best decision for the entire community, while taking into account the input of those people who believe a project should go through — especially the children. Whatever the vote, the council should thank them for doing their part to participate in a valuable exercise of our rights to have input on our government decisions.
Make no mistake, there will be a large crowd of children — in their baseball togs — making a show of force at City Hall on July 8.
I think that’s great. This is a government decision that could have a profound impact on those kids, and they should make a statement. Win, lose or draw, it is an outstanding lesson in life and the democratic process. For the kids’ sake, I think it would be terrific if they win. The hitch is, our City Council can’t let that show of force be the deciding factor.
If this is a good project, as proposed, and the opponents’ arguments are all wet, the council should approve it, and send that crowd of ballplayers and their parents home happy.
But if this project has tragic flaws, like unacceptable environmental impacts that cannot be mitigated and could leave the city on the losing end of a lawsuit, the council should muster the courage to send it back to the drawing board.
And, somewhere in between, if this is a pretty good project that would benefit from a tweak or two to make it even better before final approval, then the council should equally have the courage to require changes to be made before it moves forward.
Whatever the council does, I just hope our council members rise to the occasion and make a well-reasoned decision that takes into account the input of everyone who shows up in support or opposition of the project, while still bearing in mind their obligation to act in the best interests of the entire community.
Like I said. I’m Switzerland.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
