Recent debate about a proposed project to install four dealerships on Valencia Boulevard has pitted familiar foes against each other: the builders versus the environmentalists.
Not an unfamiliar cast in Santa Clarita these days. The builders say they are being unfairly portrayed as having little regard for the environment, and the environmentalists say they are unfairly being characterized as anti-growth, anti-schools and anti-children.
“It’s not just a dozen people,” said Teresa Savaikie, a local environmental activist. “It’s the 299 million Americans that support the Endangered Species Act.”
Savaikie and a handful of other environmentalists oppose a plan proposed by The Newhall Land and Farming Co. to build four car dealerships in the front acreage adjacent to the Hart PONY Baseball and Softball fields in Valencia.
It’s not because of the cars that will be sold on the lots, she said, it’s because of the river and what lives in it.
The City Council is scheduled to hold a special meeting July 8 to hear argument for and against the project.
As owner of the land for more than 50 years, Newhall Land wants to extend Auto Row around the corner. The softball and baseball fields will be significantly improved by the project, officials say.
However, the debate sparked when Newhall Land proposed to truck more than 550,000 cubic yards of dirt from a Saugus industrial park site to the Valencia site. Newhall Land has also said it will stabilize the riverbank so the playing fields don’t fall into the Santa Clara River during the next El Niño or La Niña storms.
Savaikie, a member of the local watchdog group, Friends of the Santa Clara River, said the method Newhall Land wants to use to reinforce the riverbank will damage the southwestern arroyo toad, the same species the city of Santa Clarita is using as an argument to fend off a proposed Transit Mixed sand and gravel mine in Soledad Canyon.
“I don’t think bank stabilization is the way to go,” Savaikie said. “We need to find a way to build this project around the habitat.” The arroyo toad is a federally listed endangered species and was spotted less than a mile away from the PONY fields, Savaikie said, adding the toads can’t burrow into the materials that will be used for the bank stabilization.
“Where are they going to go?” she asked. “It looks good to the eye, but it’s not good to the arroyo toad habitat.”
Savaikie said she wants the Hart PONY program to get its much-deserved improvements, but the project has to have everyone’s interests taken into consideration, even the toads’.
She said she recognizes that may be an uphill battle: “It’s hard to fight Newhall Land, even when the law is on your side.”
Newhall Land spokeswoman Marlee Lauffer said all the proper studies have been conducted and the work will protect the habitat.
“We feel confident through the (Natural River Management Plan) and information we are providing all the issues are resolvable,” Lauffer said.
“We still have to go through and get the permits through the various agencies,” she said, referring to final signoff by the federal Fish and Wildlife Service and the Army Corps of Engineers.
The man with the Plan
The Natural River Management Plan — which runs along Soledad Canyon Road, west, to the San Francisquito Creek junction, past the Interstate 5 bridge to Castaic Creek — was a study and planning guide for projects along the Santa Clara River. But that plan is under review by the Wildlife Service.
Wildlife Service biologist Rick Ferris said the agency wants to review the plan because arroyo toads weren’t spotted around the area when the document was drafted. The species has since been found in that area of the river by the same biologist the city hired to refute environmental documentation presented by Transit Mixed.
“We had to go back and re-consult on just the arroyo toad,” Ferris said.
Ferris said he has completed the study, but wouldn’t give the result until it goes through the review and approval process by his superiors.
“The question becomes, ‘Is it going to jeopardize the ultimate survival of the arroyo toad?’” Ferris said.
Asked what scenarios face the project, Ferris said that, if there are no impacts, the project can go on as proposed. But if the toad will be affected, then alternatives will have to be drawn.
In August 2000, the city, Newhall Land and other developers sent letters to the Wildlife Service asking that the arroyo toad critical habitat designation be withdrawn from the Santa Clara River because the species was never spotted.The agency accommodated the city’s request in February 2001.
Ferris said that decision has been remanded until his biological review is approved. The agency hasn’t been contacted about this project, he said.
Lauffer said she is sure all necessary precautions have already been taken into consideration.
The dirty dirt debate
The project calls for 554,000 cubic yards of dirt to be transported from the Centre Point Business Park near Golden Triangle Road in Saugus to the Valencia site.
Opposition to this part of the project arose because of concerns that the dirt being transported may be contaminated.
Centre Point is located just north of the former Whittaker-Bermite munitions plant, where the soil is known to be contaminated with a slew of toxins, including ammonium perchlorate, a rocket-fuel accelerate known to cause hypothyroidism in humans.
Business park owner Larry Rasmussen said soil testing found no evidence of perchlorate.
“It’s clean as a newborn baby’s behind,” Rasmussen said.
Rasmussen said Newhall Land paid for the testing to alleviate any concerns that potential polluted soil wouldn’t be moved.
Project detractors have asked the city to have an independent third party test the soil.
Rasmussen said the soil was clean because it hasn’t been used for anything and it sits upstream from the Bermite site, so contaminants flow in the opposite direction.
Lauffer agreed and said more tests will be conducted as the project moves forward.
City Planning Manager Vince Bertoni said Rasmussen wasn’t required to conduct additional environmental studies to move the dirt because his permit was approved by Los Angeles County in 1983 and he wasn’t asking to change any aspect of the project.
However, objection did arise to the amount of traffic the dirt hauling will cause on Soledad Canyon Road.
According to city documents, one truck per minute from 8:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m., Monday through Friday, will leave the Saugus business park site to dump the dirt at the Valencia Boulevard project.
Traffic calming measures have been installed to help alleviate stress on the city’s main road, and Bertoni said more modifications may occur after the project gets under way.
If you build it,
they will come
City revenues rely on the sales tax of cars along Auto Row. Figures show approximately 24 percent of the city’s tax base comes from car sales, something the City Council is interested in increasing.
The council in the past year has given the city’s financial support to the Shop Local campaign, which urges residents to purchase their cars here instead of “over the hill.”
At a recent meeting at the Hart PONY fields, Mayor Frank Ferry said it was among the council’s top priorities to keep shoppers here, and providing them with more varieties of cars to choose from will make that happen.
Lauffer said Mercedes Benz and Infiniti have expressed interest in moving into the new spots, but couldn’t confirm if a deal had been inked.
Meanwhile, the improvements slated for the Hart fields have won over most of the organization’s participants.
Dave Scripture, Hart PONY board president, recognizes the debate is going on, but is confident the city will come through.
Scripture said the league couldn’t have survived without the great hospitality of Newhall Land. Hart PONY has leased the land for $1 per year since the 1950s.
“There’s a lot of tradition here,” he said.
Newhall Land is picking up the tab for the bank stabilization and adding a sewer system for the ballpark. To boot, the company is handing over the deed to the land after the project is finished.
Lauffer said giving the land to Hart PONY continues Newhall Land’s record of contributing to the community.
As Scripture put it, “Let’s play ball!”
