It’s the second official week of the Gray Davis recall campaign. As Californians begin to examine the procedure under the microscope, all sorts of quirks are turning up.
It’s understandable that the rules are catching people off guard. Since 1911, when California voters first had the ability to recall a state office holder, there have been 32 attempts to recall a governor. None ever made it to the ballot — until last week, when Secretary of State Kevin Shelley certified the election. So, until last week, nobody ever worried much about the finer points of the process.
Now, upon examination, it seems there are some huge loopholes that need closing.
No matter what your political stripe, the process seems inherently unfair.
For starters, if Gray Davis wants to remain governor, he would have to win more than 50 percent of the vote. His successor, on the other hand, needs only a plurality. If there’s a crowded field of candidates, Davis could be replaced by somebody who wins only a tiny fraction of the popular vote.
In theory, Davis could garner, say, 40 percent of the vote, in which case he’d be removed from office. Then, he’d be replaced by someone who wins only 10 percent of the vote.
Even if Davis would be the popular choice on election day — the best of a bunch of bad apples with less than 50 percent of the vote but ahead of any challenger — he can’t be governor, because his name can’t be on the ballot to replace himself.
Under Article 2 of the state Constitution, “If the majority vote on the question is to recall, the officer is removed and, if there is a candidate, the candidate who receives a plurality is the successor. The officer may not be a candidate.”
Why not? That’s wrong. The winner on a recall ballot should be the person the greatest number of California voters want.
Most voters in the conservative Santa Clarita Valley probably won’t get too teary-eyed over this ... but consider how Republicans would feel if the shoe were on the other foot.
What if Bill Simon had been elected governor last year and a rich Democrat like Barbra Streisand or Rob Reiner decided to bankroll a recall? Simon would have to poll better than 50 percent on election day — a tough job for any mid-term politician — and if he didn’t, he’d be thrown out and Dianne Feinstein or Gray Davis would be governor.
That’s the most heinous problem with California’s recall mechanism, but there are more.
Lt. Gov. Cruz Bustamante raised a ruckus among pundits last week when he wouldn’t answer reporters’ questions over the timing of the recall and replacement elections. Had Bustamante scheduled the recall election on a separate ballot with no replacement vote, and Davis is recalled, guess who’d be governor?
The state Constitution says, “An election to determine whether to recall an officer and, if appropriate, to elect a successor shall be called...” The language should be tightened to specify that it’s always “appropriate” to hold a replacement election on the same ballot.
Finally, today, a hearing will be held in federal court to decide which voters will be able to select the next governor.
As it stands, the plan is that your vote for Davis’ replacement will count only if you also decide yes or no on the recall. If you skip the question, “Should Gov. Gray Davis be recalled?” your vote for the replacement won’t be tabulated.
That, too, is wrong. There should be no requirement to vote on every issue on a ballot. There’s no such requirement in other elections. If you’ve got mixed feelings about keeping Davis, you should nonetheless be able to cast a “what-if” vote.
Now that California’s first-ever gubernatorial recall is under way, it’s becoming apparent that some serious revisions to the state Constitution are in order.
