There’s what is legal and what is right, and the two aren’t always the same.
The Gray Davis recall offers several examples.
In theory, it’s proper for California voters to have a mechanism for removing an elected office holder who isn’t doing a good job. They shouldn’t have to wait until the next regularly scheduled election to give him the boot.
And it’s fine that any replacement candidates have only two weeks from the time the certification of the election to decide whether they’ll run. Anyone who can’t decide within two weeks isn’t serious.
And it’s perfectly OK for the election to be held within 60 to 80 days. Why wait? Politicking goes on too long in general. Let’s be done with it.
And it can’t be said that the process is closed to the common voter. In fact, the filing requirements are so simple — 65 signatures and $3,500 is all it takes for a spot on the ballot — that we could have literally 1,000 different choices, come election day.
But one of those choices will not be Gray Davis — and that’s wrong.
Under the California constitution, Davis would have to win 50 percent of the vote to keep the keys to the governor’s mansion. His replacement, should he fail, needs only a plurality. The winner is the top vote-getter among the “cast of 1,000,” even if the top vote-getter doesn’t garner 50 percent of the vote.
On Monday Davis sued the state of California to delay the election until March and place his name on the ballot.
While we disagree with the first motive — delaying the election — we can’t dispute the second.
The election shouldn’t be delayed. The state would suffer from a drawn-out campaign and none of the important business of the state would get done.
But when voters enter the polling booth on Oct. 7, they should be able to check the box for Gray Davis.
True, he could lose the recall election and still remain as governor, if he fails to win 50 percent but comes out ahead of the rest.
But it seems that the process should allow this. The next governor of California should be the person a plurality of Californians want — even if it’s Gray Davis.
Besides, if the sentiment against Davis is so strong, his detractors have nothing to fear.
The state Supreme Court is being asked to decide on Davis’ lawsuit by Aug. 31, the day the ballot language has to be finalized. The court could hand down a split decision — and we hope it does:
Keep the Oct. 7 election date, but give Gray Davis one shot in 1,000, rather than none at all.
