ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

50 Years of Information

A half-century ago, goings-on at town meetings were kept from the public. The Brown Act changed that

Imagine attending a City Council meeting and they kicked you out. If the council members made secret decisions behind closed doors. If they didn?t tell the public when or where they were meeting, or even what they were going to discuss.

Fifty years ago, these practices were entirely legal. Governing bodies of local agencies were able to take any and all of these actions, without facing prosecution.

This ability came to an end when, in 1953, a San Francisco Chronicle reporter penned a draft of the words above. The paragraph became the preamble to California?s open-meeting law, the Ralph M. Brown Act.

Named for state Assemblyman Ralph M. Brown, the act opens up to the public the deliberations and actions of its government.

?Everything really took place behind closed doors,? said Tom Newton, an attorney for the California Newspaper Publishers Association. ?If something controversial came up, they said, ?Everyone out!? and closed the doors.?

In the early 1950s, Chronicle reporter Michael Harris began to look at the problems.

Harris said he went out for a few days and talked to people in the suburbs about what occurred at their city council meetings.

?They said, ?I don?t know. That?s when they kicked us out,?? Harris said.

He began to notice a trend of closed meetings in several Bay Area public agencies.

?They didn?t tell when or where they were holding (the meetings),? he said.

In a couple of extreme examples, Harris said there was a group that attended a meeting to protest the proposed firing of an official. The agency didn?t bring up the issue during the meeting, told everybody to go home, then met again afterward and fired him.

Many school boards or city councils would meet an hour before the meeting to discuss items ahead of time, he said.

Harris went on to write 10 articles, one from each county, about the problems he had discovered. He took the articles to the University of California, Berkeley, and then talked to the League of California Cities.

They told Harris there needed to be an ordinance, and that he would have to write the preamble.

?But I?m not a lawyer,? Harris told them. ?They said, ?Exactly. You?ll write it in English so people will understand it.??

After some work, Harris wrote the preamble, and spoke to the California Newspaper Publishers Association. He said he described the act to the group, and then-San Raphael Independent Journal managing editor Jack Cramer circulated copies of it. He mailed a copy to state Assemblyman Ralph M. Brown ? who Harris said had been double-crossed in the same fashion: Issues that were voted on when Brown attended a meeting had been reversed after he left.

Brown introduced the bill, which was applied to very few groups at first, Harris said.

?We knew to knock them off one at a time, or they?d all gang up on us,? he said.

The bill carried, but had been softened, Harris said. The only thing that remains intact today is the preamble.

?By and large, city attorneys are the worst enemies of the Brown Act,? Harris said. ?What looks like a brick wall to ordinary people looks like an arc of triumph to a clever lawyer.?

The reason for this, Harris said, is because the city attorney must serve his clients before the public.

Santa Clarita City Attorney Carl Newton ? who is Tom Newton?s uncle ? said he has a healthy respect for the Brown Act, which he described as ?valiant.?

?The public has a right to know what?s going on,? Carl Newton said.

However, he added, there has to be a good balance.

?The city has the same right to remain confidential in matters regarding litigation,? he said.

It would be contrary to the interest of the community for some of these matters to be discussed in the open, he said.

Newton said since the beginning of his career as a city attorney in 1968, none of his client cities have ever been prosecuted for violating the Brown Act, including Santa Clarita.

?There have been a couple of allegations of violations,? he said, ?but the litigation never went forward.?

The Brown Act, like any other law, has to be followed carefully, Newton said. ?It requires work handling it. It occupies time to guide (the council) more carefully.

?I always advise my council that the threat of prosecution exists,? he said. ?They wouldn?t want a criminal record so I always advise them to abide by it. It?s in the best interest of the public.?

Tom Newton said he believes the Brown Act may not be as important to a majority of people.

?Most citizens in a community have never been to a (public agency) meeting,? he said. ?But there are a lot of people who do go to these meetings, and a broad cross-section ? including newspapers ? that do attend and do it on behalf of all of us.?

Newspapers are routinely present at public meetings to let people know what is going on in the community, and about decisions on issues that affect their daily lives, Tom Newton said.

While there are more broad federal open-meetings laws, each of the 50 United States have discrete and specific statutes mandating open meetings.

These laws ? including the Brown Act ? clearly define such issues as the number of members of the governing body that must be present to constitute a public meeting; under which conditions a closed meeting is allowable; how far in advance meetings must be noticed so that the public can attend if they want; and by stating that all deliberative stages of the decision-making process are considered meetings and must be open to the public.

Closed session meetings are supposed to be narrowly interpreted, Newton said. Matters that would require a closed session include pending litigation, real property transactions, labor negotiations, and personnel matters.

The reasons for holding closed sessions are usually in the public?s best interest, he said. For example, a city council would meet with its attorney to discuss pending or potential litigation in closed session so the opposition is not able to see their legal strategy, similar to attorney-client privilege.

It would also benefit the public to allowing closed sessions for real property transactions, so the seller would not be able to see the deliberations and hike up the price, he said.

Closed meetings to discuss personnel matters are usually done ?to prevent undue embarrassment,? Newton said.

Also commonly discussed in closed sessions are public security matters, ?so the bad guys won?t know the good guys? plans,? he said.

Carl and Tom Newton both agreed that many times abuses of the Brown Act are threatened with litigation, but are rarely prosecuted.

Tom Newton said the most common lament about the Brown Act is that it bares no teeth, and there needs to be more of an ability to enforce the law.

Violations of the Brown Act are punishable by both civil and criminal remedies.

Tom Newton said the civil remedies include nullification of whatever action was taken illegally behind closed doors, and the plaintiff in the case can recover attorney fees and costs from the governing body. He also said, in theory, public officials can be held criminally liable ? with a misdemeanor charge ? for taking secret action. However, that course of action has not been carried out.

?It?s been tried a few times, but the defendant has either been found not guilty or it will come up a hung jury,? he said. ?More likely what occurs is the threat of litigation,? Tom Newton said.

?Local bodies can violate and the worst thing that will happen to them is they?ll have to (vote on the action) over again,? he said. ?It doesn?t mean that no one?s ever violated (the act) ? it just hasn?t been prosecuted.

?That?s why it?s up to community newspapers to keep public officials in line.?

← Back to 2003

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:2958.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,318 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [managing editor]
  • text:valley_names [2 distinct/3 mentions: Santa Clarita, City Council]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 5, national 0