City of Santa Clarita officials said Wednesday that structures built in California after 2006 may not be as safe as they could because of a recent state decision to adopt a new set of building codes.
Last week the California Building Standards Commission voted to adopt the National Fire Protection Association 5000, building construction and safety code and NFPA 1, uniform fire code, as the state’s new safety and fire prevention codes.
A coalition of construction industry representatives had been lobbying the Building Standards Commission to adopt a different set of codes, the International Codes, because they said the codes would have the least negative consequences on the safety of residents and buildings in the state.
Ruben Barrera, a city building official, said he was opposed to the NFPA codes because they are a different format from the state’s current codes; they do not offer the best construction standards available; they are not as enforceable; and they are going to cost the residents of the state more to implement.
“I viewed both codes, and in my opinion, the International Code is the superior code,” Barrera said. “I believe buildings would be safer if they were built in compliance with the International Code which was not adopted.”
Barrera said the International Code is superior; more enforceable; has provisions that have been proven and tested; is supported by all the major groups in the construction industry; is more cost effective to enforce and comply with; and that it would lead to safer buildings in the state.
Stan Nishimura, executive director of the Building Standards Commission, said it was difficult for him to respond to Barrera’s claims.
“Those statements were made throughout the commission’s meeting,” Nishimura said. “But when the commission asked for the facts to support the statements, nothing was provided. They (the commission) felt it (NFPA) was a better, safer code that provided a higher level of safety.”
Nishimura said the Building Standards Commission made its decision to adopt the NFPA based on a recommendation from the state fire marshal.
“Although all of the model codes reviewed will require state amendments to mirror our current requirements set in statute, NFPA’s building and fire codes offer higher levels of safety than the ICC codes in many key areas,” the state fire marshal wrote in its recommendation. “For example, NFPA 5000 was the first building code drafted to include safeguards for firefighters and emergency responders.
“These safeguards are demonstrated in the code’s provisions by the higher fire-resistant rating for structural members in high-rise buildings, and by no reduction in stairway width when sprinklers are present. Also, NFPA 5000 includes provisions for existing buildings undergoing construction and establishes safety requirements according to the type of construction being completed. This constitutes a major enhancement to public safety resulting from NFPA 5000.”
Barrera said since the fire marshal doesn’t enforce building codes, the Building Standards Commission should have listened to the coalition of construction industry representatives.
“We are much more familiar with the code. We are the ones who enforce and understand it,” Barrera said. “I think special interest groups dominated that vote and that’s why they voted the way they voted.”
Robert E. Raymer, technical director of the California Building Industry Association, which is lobbying to overturn the Building Standards Commission adoption, said in a statement that the International Codes are more user-friendly documents than the NFPA 5000, in regards to common construction practices and situations.
“The rest of the country has made the decision to go with the IBC and the IRC,” Raymer wrote in a letter to the California Building Standards Commission.
“Industry and local government will incur substantial costs in order to purchase and update the reference library required if the Building Standards Commission chooses to go with the NFPA 5000 Building Code. Industry and local government employees will have to undergo extensive retraining to make the shift from the current 2001 CBC to a state code based on the NFPA 5000.”
