Is it possible for a celebrity to run the state government?
Could Britney Spears do it? Could Kobe Bryant?
The answer, of course, is yes, a celebrity could do it — as long as it’s the right celebrity. He or she would have to have the right set of skills and charisma to command respect enough to get the job done.
Ronald Reagan, a B-movie actor, made a respectable governor. More recently, wrestler Jesse Ventura demonstrated competence in Minnesota.
Reagan had one thing that Arnold Schwarzenegger doesn’t: Reagan held a highly politicized leadership position as president of the Screen Actors Guild, prior to seeking elective office.
But critics of Schwarzenegger’s lack of political experience are disingenuous when, in the next breath, they decry “politicians” and say they want someone with business experience to get the state out of its budget mess.
Schwarzenegger is a businessman of the first order.
In fact, he’s a business unto himself. For all intents and purposes, Arnold Schwarzenegger is president of his own corporation and is simultaneously its chief product.
It’s our problem, not his, that we idolize that product — and it works to his benefit.
Superstardom doesn’t come by luck or magic. To be Arnold Schwarzenegger — to succeed wildly in a cutthroat business with thousands of competitors — you’ve got to be savvy enough to hire people who are smarter and more skilled than you are in particular disciplines. You have to hire the best bankers, the best accountants, the best trainers, the best agents, the best attorneys — and you have to be able to “work the system.”
In both those areas, Schwarzenegger has an advantage over Gray Davis.
The good governor was plagued during his first term by his fatal flaws: inaction and reaction. Where proaction was needed, Davis let government positions go unfilled — and still today, many commissions lack commissioners and departmental agencies lack permanent chairs. And in reacting to a volatile energy market, Davis made bad decisions that appeared to be based more on polls than policy.
Would Schwarzenegger be hamstrung by Sacramento politicians who would regard him as a novice? If this were the 1980s, perhaps. But with term limits, the Legislature is not the impenetrable wall it once was. Sacramento no longer has a Willie Brown.
And yet Davis, who knows the political ropes, managed to let the system one-up him. Davis has failed to carry his goals through to completion — if indeed it’s clear what he stands for — and he’s got few allies to help him. Our friendless governor doesn’t get along with fellow Democrat Cruz Bustamante, so much so that the lieutenant governor is bucking the stated party line and running as a replacement candidate.
Labor unions support Davis, but what’s their alternative?
Should Davis be recalled? Yes; in retrospect the office was too big for him in the first place.
Who should replace him? Listen closely to the candidates over the next two months, and listen beyond the sound bites.
Schwarzenegger, naturally, will utter the best one-liners. He has hired top-notch political advisers to feed him rhetoric, and he’s an accomplished master at delivery. That’s his profession.
What would he do as governor? What does he stand for? And how does his platform differ from Tom McClintock’s or Bustamante’s or Arianna Huffington’s or Larry Flynt’s?
We know who’s not up to the job. Now we’ll need to evaluate the candidates carefully as Oct. 7 approaches.
Leon Worden is The Signal’s city editor.
