The eyes of the state will focus on Santa Clarita Tuesday, as the City Council decides whether to dispose of its pilot diaper recycling program.
State legislation that would add a quarter-cent sales tax on baby and adult diapers to create recycling programs across California was put on hold earlier this year, pending the outcome of an audit of Santa Clarita’s pilot program — the first in the nation.
Nearly 100 percent of targeted households participated in the city’s program, but only about 70 percent actually put their diaper bins on the curb for collection on any given week.
City staff is advising the council to dump the program.
“The whole picture just wasn’t there, so we recommended to discontinue the program,” said Travis Lange, the city’s environmental services manager.
The city launched the six-month experiment in November with Knowaste LLC, the sole maker of diaper-recycling machinery. The city purchased a diaper recycling processor from Knowaste with $250,000 in city funds and $250,000 in state funds.
The diapers are being collected from about 230 homes from four different neighborhoods in Santa Clarita. Blue Barrel Disposal Co. transports the diapers to the processor, which is housed at rival hauler Browning Ferris Industries’ facility in Sun Valley.
Ruling the six-month results inconclusive, the City Council extended the program for another three months in May. Staff members were instructed to determine whether the program could be extended city-wide, by evaluating participation rates, tonnage collected, cost, dumping fees, and the amount of waste that was actually being diverted from landfills.
Alleging that the city’s program hasn’t achieved its goals, industry groups such as the California Manufacturers and Technology Association, whose members include leading diaper manufacturers, are trying to kill the proposed diaper tax in Sacramento.
The legislation, Senate Bill 204, would levy a quarter-cent tax on personal care products — defined as “a disposable product composed of plastic and paper materials that is worn by a person of any age for the purpose of capturing human waste” — to fund municipal programs that would divert the products from California landfills.
A city staff report states that only 248 pounds of diapers were collected per child throughout the six-month period, versus the desired amount of 375 to 675 pounds.
The report said the city would collect 674 tons of diapers per year if the program were to be expanded citywide — reducing the overall amount of trash sent to landfills by less than one quarter of 1 percent.
To reach the city’s goal of 75 percent waste diversion from landfills, Santa Clarita would have to divert an additional 33 percent of its waste, or 101,000 tons, the report states.
“Although diaper recycling will provide additional diversion, resources may be better utilized if the city concentrated on other programs that yield a higher diversion for lower costs,” the report states.
Based on information provided to the city by Knowaste, the initial six-month pilot program cost $61,485.48, or about $1,845.86 per ton collected. For the last three months, processing has cost $46,852.78, or $3,520.78 per ton collected.
City staff has twice recommended that the City Council forgo the diaper recycling program. Each time the council has voted to move ahead with it.
If the council votes to cancel the program Tuesday, Knowaste will be instructed to sell the diaper recycling processor for $250,000. If there is no buyer for the machine, Knowaste will pay the city $100,000.
q q q
Residents who’ve been recycling diapers in Santa Clarita would like to see the effort continue, a city survey shows.
The report states that of 118 participants who responded, 37 percent were unwilling to bear an additional fee for the service.
However, the report adds that most of the 37 percent said their children are almost potty-trained.
Knowaste spokeswoman Fiona Hutton said most participating residents loved the recycling program and would accept a nominal fee for it.
“The residents overwhelmingly are extremely excited about the program, even if there was a fee attached to it,” Hutton said.
Diaper recycling, which is routine only in the Netherlands and parts of Canada, has put Santa Clarita on the map, Hutton said.
Several cities have contacted Hutton, expressing their interest in testing the program, she said.
Despite the failure of the program to divert as much trash as expected, “every little bit that you can recycle reduces waste sent to landfills,” Hutton said.
She said it’s also important to consider the nature of the waste that’s being diverted.
“Diverting human waste from landfills is a huge benefit,” Hutton said. “How do you place a cost on that?”
Hutton said Knowaste has asked the city to delay its verdict until a future City Council meeting, but there is no indication from the council’s agenda report that the decision will be postponed.
