There is a hidden up side to the free-for-all that has become the race to replace Gov. Gray Davis should he be ousted in the October recall election:
For once, for perhaps the first and only time we will ever witness, a moderate stands a chance in a statewide election.
We have, in this space, pointed out several key flaws in the process that is in place for the recall of Davis.
The down sides include the fact that Davis cannot compete to be his own replacement: If the voters decide in favor of a recall, the next governor will be the person who gets the most votes among the challengers on “Part 2” of the ballot — and Davis’ name cannot be on that list.
Further, considering the large number of candidates — 135 have qualified — the winner is likely to be someone with a relatively small percentage of the vote.
So, it’s entirely conceivable that Davis could be the top vote-getter — by virtue of his tally in “Part 1” — and still be ousted from office. It’s a process that carries some significant built-in unfairness.
We have also said, however, that the time has clearly come for a change at the top of California’s government.
So when voters go to the polls to make that change, they will face an admittedly difficult choice: Choosing from a list of more than 100 candidates, even after some of the lunatic fringe candidates were weeded out by the process of verifying their supporters’ signatures on their campaign applications.
Despite the aforementioned problems with the process, what that means is California voters may truly have a chance to elect someone with a legitimate claim to the middle of the road.
This is due, simply, to the absence of a primary.
Voters will go to the polls just once to decide whether Davis is out, and, in turn, to choose his replacement.
There will be no “first round,” in which the Republicans and Democrats choose their nominees before the real choice is made.
So often in primaries — not just for governor but also for many other elected offices — it seems as if the Republicans’ choice is someone from the right wing of their party, and the Democrats’ choice is someone from the left wing of theirs.
The result in the general election is typically a choice between two extremes, and voters who might consider themselves true moderates are left without a candidate to champion.
That may be different in this particular election. With no primary election, the field may yield legitimate moderate contenders, offering an unusual option for voters who prefer neither the extreme right nor the extreme left:
Someone from the middle. Who would have thought?
