The city will defend itself in a lawsuit alleging Santa Clarita did not enforce its oak tree ordinance when it approved the Needham Ranch business park earlier this year.
City Attorney Carl Newton said Tuesday that the City Council instructed the defense against the lawsuit.
Three environmental groups — the Santa Clarita Oak Conservancy, who filed the suit with the California Oak Foundation and Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment — filed suit July 24 against the city of Santa Clarita and project developer Mark Gates over the 508-acre business park in Newhall. The lawsuit also raises concerns over the city’s hillside ordinance and an over-statement of water supply.
Santa Clarita’s oak tree ordinance calls for the city “to require the preservation of all healthy oak trees unless compelling reasons justify the removal of such trees.”
Plans for the industrial park call for the removal of 1,408 oak trees, of which nearly half are dead or fire damaged. None of the trees intended for removal are heritage oaks.
Newton said the city and the environmental organizations have already had one phone conference to discuss possible settlements, but there was no resulting agreement. A second conference is scheduled for Sept. 11.
“There’s a minimal chance of settling this case,” Newton said.
SCOPE President Lynne Plambeck said she hopes for a different outcome.
“We’re hoping there can be some resolution to this,” she said.
Plambeck said she disagrees with the city’s approval to cut down mature trees at a time when Santa Clarita’s air quality has become a leading issue of concern.
In the summer 2003 SCOPE newsletter, Cynthia Neal Harris, a board member of the Santa Clarita Oaks Conservancy, said “We have never had a project in the history of the city of Santa Clarita that allowed this many oak removals. Oaks are well-known for their value in sequestering ... carbon from the air. At a time when our air quality is the worst in (Los Angeles) County, we should not be removing the very trees that will help us reduce our air pollution.”
