We have long complained that the campaign finance rules in the city of Santa Clarita create a playing field evoking just one reaction:
Tilt!
Contributions by individuals are limited to $250 per candidate, per election cycle, while political action committees have no such limitation on either the contributions they receive or the funds they spend to help get a candidate elected.
We saw the ramifications of this flawed set of rules in the most recent City Council election, held in April.
While there were, as is to be expected, various instances of individual contributors bending, breaking or simply misunderstanding the rules, the vast majority of individual contributors stuck to the $250 limit. Those rules, of course, are always subject to contributors and campaigns seeking to find “wiggle room,” ways to legally funnel more money to a candidate from one source.
What really rankled, though, was the sudden, late-breaking and heavy-hitting spending by PACs, which funded slick mailers and last-minute phone banks.
Unlike individual contributions to candidates, contributions to PACs have no $250 cap — so a single donor could simply funnel thousands and thousands of dollars into a PAC, thereby side-stepping the contribution limit and improving the donor’s ability to “buy” an election.
Just one example from the April council election: Waste Management Inc., the Texas-based parent company of two local trash haulers, threw $32,000 into the Santa Clarita City Council campaign. WMI’s PAC donations were in turn spent to support three candidates — without the hassle of the contribution limit with which all direct campaign donors had to comply.
There were other major PAC donors, too. And, apparently, the contributions were all legal.
At long last, one member of the Santa Clarita City Council is proposing a change to those rules.
Councilman Cameron Smyth says he plans to submit an ordinance for approval by his fellow council members that would apply the $250 individual contribution limit to PACs, too.
What that means is, a single donor couldn’t inject thousands of dollars into a campaign in one fell swoop, but would instead have to muster the support the same way everyone else does: One donor at a time, $250 at a time.
The PAC, in turn, would be allowed to spend whatever it can raise in support of a candidate, but the PAC would no longer be able to reel in a single check to cover its campaign nut. There’d be a little more heavy lifting involved, to say the least.
What would this do?
It would force all donors to play by the same rules. Those who choose to donate directly to a candidate’s campaign would still be able to make their $250 contribution, and those who would rather give their money to a PAC would be able to donate an equivalent amount. But no longer would a single donor — for example, an out-of-state multinational company — be allowed to simply cut one check and tilt the scales in favor of its chosen candidates.
The council should approve Smyth’s proposal, and change the message from “Tilt!” to “Level!”
