While several labor organizations are advocating passage of legislation that would provide all workers with health-care coverage, several business organizations believe it would worsen the state’s economic crisis.
Senate Bill 2, scheduled for a vote in the Senate and Assembly prior to the end of the legislative year at midnight Friday, would require businesses with more than 20 employees to pay at least 80 percent of the premium for their employees’ health insurance.
The bill, authored by Sens. John Burton, D-San Francisco, and Jackie Speier, D-San Mateo, would also require businesses with more than 200 employees to provide coverage to their employees’ dependents.
Alternatively, the bill would allow companies to pay an undetermined fee to the state for pooled, state-purchased health-care coverage for their uninsured employees.
While labor organizations such as the International Longshore and Warehouse Union believe SB 2 would be a boon for California’s six million uninsured residents, some economists believe the bill would force employers to lay off employees or move out of state.
Michael Haviland, economic development director for the city of Santa Clarita, said the city didn’t have an official position on the bill.
Jack Kyser, chief economist for the Los Angeles County Economic Development Corp., recently completed an analysis of the bill for the California Chamber of Commerce. He said while he agreed something should be done to help the state’s uninsured workers, SB 2 is not the answer.
“We feel it is being rushed through because of the possible recall of the governor,” Kyser said Wednesday. “This is going to have some very significant ramifications on California businesses.”
More than half of the small and medium-sized businesses surveyed reported that they feared SB 2 would hurt profits, payrolls, benefits and competitiveness. Some businesses also reported that they may have to lay off workers, close down or move out of state if the bill is enacted.
“There are already a lot of cost pressures on California businesses,” Kyser said. “The business base in California isn’t large Fortune 500 companies, it is small to medium-sized firms, and they are already operating in a very tough environment. This is just going to make hiring people more expensive.”
The report showed SB 2 would cost medium and large businesses more than $5.7 billion to cover uninsured workers and their dependents.
He said similar legislation enacted in other states has hampered economic growth. In Hawaii, he said, the state’s mandatory health coverage plan has discouraged dependent coverage and slowed wage growth in covered industries. He said Massachusetts’ plan collapsed in the early 1990s, and today the state uses federal matching funds to cover uninsured parents and children.
Kyser said although he believes the state Senate and the Assembly will pass the bill Friday, people in general need to re-examine how the economy really works.
“Legislators need to understand where tax revenues come from. It all starts with business,” Kyser said.
