They can see him coming from across the quad. Immediately they begin tugging at shirts and pulling up pants.
This routine goes on most of the lunch hour at Saugus High School when Assistant Principal Frank Ferry makes his rounds. Known as the “belly button fairy,” he calls out to different students asking how they’re doing or makes a comment on their attire.
As Ferry heads up the steps, a freshman girl, wearing a small red shirt with spaghetti straps, isn’t fast enough with the tugging.
“Come on over here,” he says.
She knows immediately.
“My belly button was NOT hanging out,” said Jackie Love, 14, as she and Ferry head to the office for a change of clothes and a citation.
So goes the year of the belly buttons.
q q q
Some blame it on the warm weather; others on the fashion industry and teenage role models. But others recognize it’s an age-old battle between young and old that is never more evident than in our educational institutions.
Ask any adult who has witnessed a teenager coming or going from school and you’ll hear, “How in the heck did they get away with wearing that to school?”
Dress codes — many parents say they don’t even know if there are ones, and if there are, they say school administrators do not enforce them.
Whether it’s bare midriffs or pants that seem to be falling off, it’s a battle to keep up with current teenage style, and according to school officials, it’s a battle that changes every year when new and more provocative clothing hits the stores.
q q q
There is a dress code for the William S. Hart Union High School District and each school site either adds to or defines the list. Dress codes are reviewed every couple of years and parents are provided with the dos and don’ts at the beginning of the school year.
The district dress code is relatively simple. Clothes must be safe and conducive to a learning environment. They must be free of gang-type insignias and accessories. Bare skin such as very short skirts and midriff-exposing tops are not allowed.
With school beginning in the middle of August and temperatures reaching 100 degrees, beach attire seems status quo for many teenage girls.
“It used to be baggy pants for the boys was a big problem, but this year it’s definitely the girls,” said Ruth Port, assistant principal at Hart High School. “But I’d say about 90 percent of the kids dress appropriately for school.”
When in infraction occurs, students either call their parents for a change of clothing or are given a T-shirt to wear over their clothes for the remainder of the day.
The T-shirts at Saugus High have big pink lettering proclaiming the wearer as “dress code challenged.”
Hart district Assistant Superintendent Leslie Crunelle said determining what is modest is harder to measure than other clear-cut infractions.
“Although there are lines that many of us would see as immodest, there are some gray areas,” she said.
The absolutes are clothing that promote drug or alcohol abuse and anything that states prejudices and invokes violence.
“We can absolutely enforce dress codes, but we cannot restrict freedom of speech and freedom of expression,” she said. “Because it’s a public school, you can enforce certain kinds of freedom of speech like gay bashing.”
For the classroom teacher, enforcing dress codes takes away from instructional time, but many say it’s necessary.
“We’re in the middle,” said Saugus teacher Orval Garrison. “It’s either you’re damned if you do and you’re damned if you don’t.”
Garrison believes that teenagers need dress codes because they will always try to push the envelope when it comes to school rules.
“That’s a fact which is neither abnormal or unnatural. If you don’t draw the line somewhere, kids will always want to take it to the next level,” he said. “(Enforcing the dress code) could take away from instructional time in the beginning until (the students’) see that the administration is holding the line.”
q q q
A popular trend for many school districts who were concerned instructional time was being taken away from the school day by dress code enforcement was to initiate a uniform policy.
La Mesa Junior High became the first school in the Hart district to have a school uniform as soon as the school was open 10 years ago. It received huge parental support and the students were allowed to help select the uniforms.
Shortly after, Placerita and Sierra Vista Junior High and Castaic Middle School initiated their own uniform policies. Only Arroyo Seco remained uniform-free for two reasons — the district needed an option for parents and students who decided uniforms were not for them and they had a principal who held the line on dress codes.
“Parents supported us and we didn’t need uniforms,” said Jacque Snyder, the then-principal at Arroyo Seco and now principal at soon-to-open Golden Valley High School.
Hats were a good example of dress code problems back then, she said. It was a popular practice for students to knock someone’s baseball cap off during the day and throw it on the roof. Snyder said “no more hats” and after a couple of weeks of enforcing the no-hat policy, students got the message.
Snyder said dress codes are another way to teach students what is appropriate.
“School is like a place of business,” she said. “This is where they come to do their job.”
Some parents like the uniforms, but other’s decided to challenge it and sought legal advice. It was determined that school districts needed to add a clause to the uniform policy stating students were allowed to opt out of wearing uniforms without transferring schools.
Soon there were so many students not wearing uniforms at Castaic and Sierra Vista, the schools decided, without parental support, the policy was dead and stopped encouraging uniforms. Placerita and La Mesa had their share of student’s opting out, but both are still strong uniform-only campuses.
q q q
Parent Jeanine Hornbrook’s daughter just entered Hart High School as a freshman. Hornbrook was in favor of the Placerita uniform policy and said she now has daily conversations with her daughter on appropriate high school attire.
She admits that her daughter wears low-cut jeans and shirts “with just a little midriff showing.” She knows there is a dress code at the school, but didn’t think it was enforced.
Hornbrook also recognizes the overwhelming amount of students on campus and how hard it must be to enforce the rules.
For many parents of today’s teens, the clothing style might look somewhat familiar. Hip huggers and halter tops were standard wear during the 70s and have made a big come back, although, some parents argue, the styles are somewhat skimpier. There are also parents old enough to remember when girls had to wear dresses and nylons to school and boys were required to wear shirts with collars. The boys’ hair was not allowed to be long enough to touch their collars.
Once dress codes were relaxed to include pants for girls and longer hair for boys, students in the 70s, like those before them, “pushed the envelope” when it came to wearing outlandish styles. Many will admit their schools just gave up trying to enforce any type of dress code.
q q q
Students who were interviewed said there should be a dress code, but were divided on what was appropriate and how school officials handle the situation.
“I don’t mind the dress code, but I don’t like the way it’s (enforced),” said Rachel Down, 17, a senior at Saugus High School.
Down said most of the students dress appropriately, but some like to stretch the limit. She doesn’t think the shirts have to completely cover up stomachs, but said many girls wear sweatshirts over their clothes while on campus.
Ferry said 142 girls have already been written up for dress code violations during the first month of school, compared to two boys.
The Saugus News Network, the on-campus video class, has made a series of dress code videos that are played during morning announcements. One video, titled “Girls Gone Wild,” shows girls on campus, lifting shirts to expose their belly buttons to the song “Bad Boys.”
Ferry knows many of the students by first name and they freely share their opinion on the dress codes with him. Cheerleaders Jaime Crouch, Jessica Bleifer and Taryn Schutz said they didn’t have a problem with the dress codes, but thought some of the new styles were a little outlandish.
The Hollister brand is an example of over-the-top, Crouch said, with the skirts measuring about 7 inches total.
“It’s definitely made for petite girls,” she said.
Another brand, whose acronym is prominently displayed on its shirt is French Connection United Kingdom, has caught the eye of administrators.
Ferry said parents are asking schools to enforce dress codes.
“If there is a girl dressed like Britney Spears sitting next to a boy in geometry who is trying to figure out proofs, who’s going to catch his eye?” he said.
While Ferry finishes writing the citation for freshman Jackie Love and hands her a substitute shirt, he tells her she’s young and needs to begin her high school career with a good attitude.
At the moment, she doesn’t agree.
“I think the dress code is inconsistent and there are more things that are distracting like mohawk (haircuts) and piercings,” Love said. “Shouldn’t high school prepare you for the real world?”
Ferry smiles as she leaves the room.
“If your biggest problem is dress codes,” Ferry said, “you’ve got it pretty good."
