The Planning Commission postponed a decision on whether Carousel Ranch should be allowed to operate in Sand Canyon so the organization can instead apply for a temporary permit to appease neighbors’ concerns.
Carousel Ranch, which operates nonprofit commercial stables for a program that provides equestrian therapy to disabled children and young adults, had been located at Atlasta Ranch from January 1999 to December 2002, when its lease expired.
Since that time, Carousel Ranch’s founders have been seeking an alternative, permanent site to house the program.
According to a city staff report, Carousel Ranch began operating at the location at 26101 Ravenhill Road, near Placerita Canyon Road and Sand Canyon Road, in January, without city approval. The minor use permit would have allowed such a program to continue indefinitely in that location.
Residents told the commission they were concerned of the potential effects from a permit allowing commercial operations to exist in their residential neighborhood.
“It has nothing to do with Carousel Ranch,” said resident Sandra Jackman, who lives adjacent to Carousel Ranch’s location. “It has to do with the permit being applied to the property.”
By postponing a decision on the minor use permit, the Planning Commissioners suggested Carousel Ranch to use that time — until it comes before them again Oct. 21 — to request to withdraw their application for a minor use permit, and apply for a temporary use permit.
A temporary permit would allow the program to continue operating at the Sand Canyon location for a defined amount of time, while it continues its search for a permanent location elsewhere.
The commission’s unanimous decision to postpone the item followed more than two hours of public testimony, in which Carousel Ranch defended itself from residents’ complaints and the residents defended themselves from “personal attacks” by a Carousel Ranch leader.
Murray Siegel, president of Carousel Ranch’s board of directors, told the Planning Commission none of the neighbors came to talk to the organization directly about their concerns, and disagreed with the residents’ laundry list of complaints.
Carousel Ranch’s location in Sand Canyon is temporary, Siegel said, until it is able to secure a permanent place to provide its services.
“The location has always been temporary to us,” Siegel said. “Why didn’t (the neighbors) use that energy to help us find a permanent home?”
Further, he said the horses do not move quickly enough to kick up dust, as neighbors alleged, and the loudest noise from the property is “the sound of kids laughing” while riding horses.
Siegel roused jeers from residents at the meeting when he said the source of the neighbors’ “self-serving” antagonism is the disabled children who utilize the ranch.
“They want to hide us away so they don’t have to see what they don’t want to think about,” Siegel said.
The allegation appalled residents and commissioners alike.
“I am astonished at what Murray Siegel said about these people here,” said Commissioner Dennis Ostrom.
Resident Dennis McGee, who spoke to the commission opposed to Carousel Ranch’s permit request, said he had worked with organizations for disabled and handicapped children, and did not like to hear Siegel’s accusation.
“I wasn’t angry until I got here,” said Sand Canyon resident Marvin Carter. “Now I’m terribly upset.”
Jeanne Hammonds, who also lives near the Carousel Ranch location, said the issue is an emotional one because of the children involved. She added that her husband worked with autistic children for 14 years, and that “I paid my dues.”
Resident Lance Willis said Siegel “bad-mouthed the entire community of Sand Canyon with his comments.”
“I think he will pay for what he has done,” Willis said.
