As the future unfolds it is likely that the victims of the World Trade Center collapse will not be limited to those who perished in it. That woeful roster may well include residents and workers who breathed its toxic spew throughout the days and weeks that followed its catastrophic implosion on Sept. 11, 2001.
Were these folks cavalier about their health by going back to their homes and work so soon after the calamity? It does not appear so. Seems members of our government told them it was safe to breathe the air.
This concern is not based on conjecture. Nor is it partisan mudslinging. It stems from information offered by Nikki Tinsley, inspector general of the Environmental Protection Agency — our nation’s chief overseer of environmental health.
In a recent interview, Tinsley said shortly after the WTC was destroyed her agency had prepared cautionary reports on the potential dangers of what was circulating in the air, both at Ground Zero and in nearby neighborhoods. But somehow those memos got watered down within the White House, sanitized and regurgitated back to the public.
Deleting cautionary statements, the missives reassured the locals — men, women and children — saying it was OK to go back to their homes and businesses.
Of course it’s risky to dive into a vaporous cloud of toxic gases swirling with asbestos, dioxins, lead, pulverized glass, concrete and other particulates. Within the mix were potent carcinogens and mutagens — dastardly molecules that can set up shop in your lungs and immune systems, causing chronic, debilitating illness, grave cancers and even transformations of DNA.
Knowing how New Yorkers don’t take kindly to B.S., my guess is they won’t be taking this information lying down. And neither should we.
Evidently, the misleading messages, Tinsley explained, were for security, public relations and the desire to reopen Wall Street.
Ah. We had to get back on our (financial) feet.
Maybe that mindset partly explains the hefty bonus Richard Grasso, the ungodly overpaid chairman and chief exec of the New York Stock Exchange, was rewarded with for re-opening the Stock Exchange six days after the epic catastrophe.
Health officials have reported that thousands of New Yorkers have developed chronic respiratory ailments and chemical sensitivities since breathing the cloud.
Perhaps the White House will discount these concerns, but respected physicians do not.
Dr. Philip Landrigan, director of environmental and occupational medicine at Mount Sinai School of Medicine in Manhattan and a leading expert on asbestos toxicity, reports such small and dangerous particles, the kind that were circulating in the air for weeks after Sept. 11, can easily penetrate deep into the lungs. Asbestos is a known carcinogen.
Dr. Alan Fein, chief of pulmonary and critical care medicine at North Shore-Long Island Jewish Health System, has treated patients with what he calls “World Trade Center syndrome,” respiratory distress stemming from exposures near Ground Zero. He expects there will be more.
A study released Wednesday from scientists at UC Davis voiced deep concerns for the thousands of workers and inhabitants of nearby buildings who breathed in Ground Zero’s long-smoldering chemical mist. Lead study author Thomas Cahill, a professor of physics and engineering, called the six-week gas cloud of toxic metals, acids, and organics “brutal.”
My nature has always been to respect my parents, teachers and national leaders. But this news really jars my confidence in the latter.
I do not want to think our government saw saving face and jump-starting our economy as more precious than safeguarding innocent lives. And I don’t want to worry that those same heads that beckoned New Yorkers to get back to their roosts have anything to do with decision-making on where we send our soldiers.
Sure, we are in a necessary war against terrorism.
I just want to know who our allies really are.
Diana Sevanian is a Signal staff writer. Her commentary appears Saturdays and she can be reached by e-mail at [email protected].
