It’s a tough job.
Playing God, that is.
It’s just one of many job requirements our city leaders may face when they run for election.
It’s not always by choice. It’s not always a result of political arrogance.
Sometimes, our elected and appointed leaders face such a role simply by virtue of the choices they must make; occasionally, it seems as if King Solomon is standing before our local municipal decision-makers and saying, “Cut the baby in half, so that each woman who claims to be the mother can have half each.”
The Santa Clarita City Council and Planning Commission do more than enable local soccer moms to have a new shopping center to buy snacks for the team. They have more power than saving an oak tree here and losing another there.
Tuesday night, Santa Clarita’s Planning Commission had the chore of playing God. And we don’t envy their job one bit.
On Tuesday, the five men and women on the Planning Commission had the responsibility to decide whether a disabled child would continue having a reason to smile, though it meant sacrifices to longtime residents who would be new neighbors of Carousel Ranch. They also had to decide whether a man who’s seen better times would have a place to sleep when the temperatures begin to drop this winter, though it meant a families just hundreds of yards away may sleep less peacefully, knowing the homeless shelter is down the street.
They’re tough decisions.
Many are quick to point their fingers and allege snobbery by those who don’t want a homeless shelter located down the street from their home. But where should it go? The fact is that the shelter has to go somewhere. Most everyone can agree, it’s a matter of finding the best location for it.
Sand Canyon residents who opposed a commercial operation in their residential neighborhood were called “self-serving” and “cold-hearted” people by Carousel Ranch leader Murray Siegel. He said his classification was based on letters written to the city. Those letters contain specific complaints about the organization’s use of the property — not one referenced the children who participate at Carousel Ranch, or the therapeutic services the programs provides. Siegel, to his credit, has apologized for his comments.
Regardless, the exchange illustrates the sort of intense emotions that surround these debates, when noble missions like helping the homeless and disabled children come up against quality-of-life concerns raised by residents who want only to protect their neighborhoods.
Similar to the situation with the homeless shelter, Carousel Ranch has been unable to find a better location. Officials from both Carousel Ranch and the Santa Clarita Community Development Corp., which runs the winter shelter, say they have been actively looking for a new, permanent location. Where are they supposed to operate in the meantime?
The Planning Commission’s decision to ask Carousel Ranch to apply for a temporary permit — instead of one that would permanently allow commercial use on the Sand Canyon property — is commendable. It was the right action to assure neighbors they will maintain the peaceful lifestyle they work hard to afford, while at the same time assuring disabled children and young adults who receive therapy at Carousel Ranch that they will continue to have an activity they enjoy.
And the commissioners who decided to allow the shelter to again use the Via Princessa Metrolink Station will ensure that many of Santa Clarita’s homeless will have a roof over their heads this winter.
We understand the sacrifices the neighbors of Carousel Ranch and the Canyon Country residents near the homeless shelter are making — some, involuntarily — and we ask these residents to have patience. We must all remember that we are blessed for what we do have. That’s not to make light of the concerns voiced by those residents; it’s merely recognition of the extreme degree of difficulty that accompanies these decisions.
Meanwhile, we remain sincerely hopeful that better long-term solutions for these issues can be found — without cutting the baby in half.
