The City Council will decide Thursday which company will be awarded Santa Clarita’s lucrative solid waste contracts — reducing local residents’ trash rates by as much as $5.88 per month.
City officials announced Monday they are recommending the City Council award Burrtec Waste Industries the trash contracts, citing cost, the provision of a materials recovery facility, or MRF, and recycling efforts.
The recommendation, if approved, leaves behind Waste Management Inc. — the parent company for Blue Barrel Disposal and Santa Clarita Disposal — and Consolidated Disposal Service, the two incumbent companies that handle 85 percent and 15 percent of the city’s trash, respectively.
“We’re very pleased with the results of the (bidding) process,” City Manager Ken Pulskamp said at a press conference Monday. “We’re going to get significantly lower rates, and increased diversion and services programs for our residents.”
“Burrtec provides the best overall value to the city,” he said.
Pulskamp said one of the biggest factors behind the staff recommendation was a provision in Burrtec’s contract to build a MRF and give the city the option to buy the facility at the end of its term.
“This is a big deal to the city because it gives us a solid, strong solid waste position,” Pulskamp said.
According to a report from the city’s trash consultant, obtaining the MRF would be worth about $1.8 million to the city.
Blue Barrel Disposal also agreed to construct a MRF — however, it is not a material condition of the contract with the city, which means that if Blue Barrel does not build the MRF the city can’t find the company in default of the contract.
“We can’t hold them to build the MRF, we’re not contractually obligated,” said Assistant City Manager Jill Fosselman.
If Blue Barrel builds a MRF and decides to sell it, she said, the city has first right of refusal. However, the company is not obligated to sell the MRF if it doesn’t want to.
Under the terms of Burrtec’s contracts with the city, the company would also provide a fleet of all-new alternative fuel trucks for collecting trash, which Pulskamp said will help air quality.
Blue Barrel agreed to provide alternative fuel vehicles, but they would not be new, Pulskamp said.
Burrtec has also agreed to empty an unlimited number of street trash and recycling cart containers twice a week, and will pick up street litter on a monthly basis. The city’s request for proposals asked for the collection on a quarterly basis.
Pulskamp said Burrtec would be able to increase the city’s diversion rates by up to 35 percent by beginning mixed waste processing for certain commercial accounts for no additional costs. The program would target about 50 percent to 65 percent of businesses that don’t already have a recycling program and that have a high percentage of recyclables in the waste stream. Burrtec would collect and sort the recyclable materials from the waste stream, diverting the extra materials from being landfilled.
Pulskamp added that Burrtec has offered to implement a food waste recycling program for residential customers. The company would provide an 18-inch air-tight container to collect organic kitchen waste, which would then be recycled with green waste and made into mulch.
The city had requested that the contracted hauler pay a fee of $2.50 per ton of recyclables collected for the city to use in awarding city beautification grants to nonprofit organizations. Pulskamp said Burrtec has offered to increase the fee to $5.50 per ton, which would total at least $235,000 by the end of the contracts.
The commercial trash contract goes into effect next year and would last for nine years, while the seven-year residential contract begins in 2006. The two contracts are timed so each would expire at the same time, in 2013.
In its contract with the city, Blue Barrel offered to give senior citizens a 20-percent discount, rather than the 15-percent discount as requested by the city.
Consolidated Disposal agreed to use new alternative fuel trucks, and would also collect an unlimited amount of street containers. The company said it would begin a pilot food waste program, and will offer free green waste drop-offs at its Chiquita Canyon Landfill.
The final factor in the city staff’s recommendation, Pulskamp said, is that “the city’s current haulers have been unsuccessful in helping the city meet (state-mandated diversion) requirements.”
q q q
The council voted in March 2002 to put its $135-million solid-waste franchise agreements out to competitive bid after failing to meet the 50-percent diversion rate mandated by the state.
Assembly Bill 939, the California Integrated Waste Management Act, became law in 1989 and called for municipalities to divert 50 percent of their solid waste from landfills by 2000. If a city fails to meet the mandated rate, it could face fines of up to $10,000 per day.
The city reported a 68,000-ton anomaly in its 1999 diversion rate. The amount of trash going to landfills was up from 115,596 tons in 1998 to 183,738 tons the following year, resulting in a 25-percent diversion rate. According to those figures, Santa Clarita diverted half as much trash from landfills in 1999 as it had diverted in 1998.
An environmental consulting firm hired by the city said improper reporting by Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita Disposal was to blame for the 1999 spike in the city’s numbers. The consultant’s preliminary report showed the city’s numbers fell because Blue Barrel erroneously attributed trash to the city that was actually generated in surrounding, unincorporated county territory.
In February, the state Integrated Waste Management Board approved Santa Clarita’s 42-percent diversion rate for the year 2000, even though it fell short of meeting the mandated 50 percent rate.
The board ruled that the city had made a “good faith effort” to reach the state’s diversion goals, and extended the city’s deadline to meet the 50-percent target until Dec. 31, 2004.
Six trash haulers submitted proposals for the city’s residential and commercial trash contracts in May. The city narrowed the field to three haulers in June, ousting Browning Ferris Industries, Crown Disposal Co., and E.J. Harrison & Sons. The three remaining haulers — Blue Barrel, Burrtec and Consolidated — proposed the lowest rates for both the residential and commercial contracts, based on rate revenues for the first year.
q q q
Santa Clarita residents currently pay $22.13 per month for trash collection. Under the new contracts residents will pay during the first year of service $16.25 if Blue Barrel is selected, $16.46 if Burrtec is selected, and $18.29 if Consolidated is selected.
“It’s not a decision that can be made solely on price,” Pulskamp said. “It’s very close.”
The residential and commercial contracts are worth more than $100 million to the contracted hauler.
Blue Barrel General Manager Chris Fall said Monday he wasn’t sure the contracts received a proper evaluation from the city’s staff.
“A MRF seemed to be the deciding factor,” Fall said. “We still believe that we made the best proposal, and we’re still the low bidder.”
Fall criticized city staff for overlooking Blue Barrel’s “Do It Now” proposal, which would implement the reduced trash collection rates at the end of this year, rather than waiting until the residential contract begins in 2006.
The proposal would reduce trash rates 21 percent, saving residents more than $4 million over time.
As a second part of its “Do It Now” proposal, Blue Barrel would cut trash collection and recycling costs to area school districts. Schools would be charged only the cost of disposal (tipping fees), with refuse bins provided free of charge.
The offer is good only if Santa Clarita gives Blue Barrel a 10-year exclusive contract through 2016 — longer than the term called for in the city’s request for proposals.
Fall said Blue Barrel would not object to keeping the “Do It Now” proposal on the table.
“I’m baffled as to why the city’s not still considering it,” Fall said.
Burrtec Vice President Eric Herbert said he was pleased upon hearing the staff’s recommendation, and looks forward to discussing issues with the City Council on Thursday.
Consolidated General Manager Matt Terrell did not return phone calls to comment Monday.
q q q
The city’s request for proposals requires the contracted hauler to be responsible for paying any fines the city could incur if it does not meet the 50-percent diversion rate. Further, the city can fine the hauler as much as $10,000 per quarter that the hauler cannot document verification of 50-percent diversion.
In its proposal to the city, Blue Barrel made exception to meeting the city’s recycling goals, as well as indemnification for the AB 939 fines. The company said it should only be responsible to pay the city’s fines if Blue Barrel fails to reach 50 percent diversion, and if the company is found to have not made a good-faith effort. (The city’s request for proposals allowed for the possibility of contracts for commercial and residential service going to separate haulers, and non-franchised roll-off bins would still be allowed — so it is possible that, even if one hauler makes the 50 percent rate, the city as a whole may not.)
All exceptions made by Blue Barrel and Consolidated were removed through the negotiation process, Fosselman said.
The City Council will review the signed residential and commercial contracts for each company at a special meeting Thursday at 6 p.m. in council chambers, located on the first floor of City Hall, 23920 Valencia Blvd.
