There’s at least one area where we agree with Knowaste President Roy Brown: If dirty diapers and other waste products can be recycled, then it’s a good idea to try to do so.
Santa Clarita residents don’t want to see their canyons turned into landfills, and the alternative is recycling.
The real improvement will come when Santa Clarita starts using a recycling center known as a materials recovery facility, or MRF. That will transform recycling from a voluntary, consumer-side system to a mandatory, hauler-driven system.
But even with an MRF, diapers will go to the landfill unless there’s a special way to process them.
That’s where Knowaste comes in. The company convinced the City Council earlier this year to run a trial program, the first of its kind in the nation, to test its patented diaper-recycling technology. The idea was that if it met certain criteria for success, the council would implement diaper recycling citywide.
With that in mind, the council included diaper recycling when it put the city’s trash-hauling contracts to bid. Haulers were required, among other things, to show the city how much they’d charge to run a diaper-recycling program using Knowaste’s technology.
Meanwhile, diaper recycling was tested in selected neighborhoods. Results were mixed. Residents with babies generally liked the program, as reflected in the participation rate and in their comments on surveys. And after some early glitches, the technology worked.
The problem, from the city’s standpoint, was that the tonnage of diapers collected fell short.
Roy Brown questions the city’s methodology, but there’s another factor that has stopped us from embracing the program.
Based on the city’s numbers, the program doesn’t deliver enough bang for the buck.
According to the haulers’ bids, diaper recycling would cost every Santa Clarita household — with or without babies — 66 to 81 cents per month, or roughly $9 per year, while improving the overall recycling rate by less than one-quarter of one percent.
A city staff report notes that there are other things, like education and other recycling programs, that could make a bigger dent in the city’s recycling rate.
For that reason, it has been our recommendation that the city kill the diaper recycling program and focus on other things that would divert more trash from landfills.
Let us emphasize that point. We’re not necessarily saying the $9 per year shouldn’t be spent.
When we began looking at waste-hauling costs a year and a half ago, we observed that our current residential trash rate of $22.13 was among the highest in California. That’s not because the city was spending oodles on recycling. Rather, it appeared there was a gross profit margin — and by “gross” we mean “grotesque” — for the trash haulers.
With the next trash contracts, residential rates will come down, probably to the $14-to-$18 level. Even then, there will likely be room to increase the amount that is spent on recycling programs. This should happen.
And while we believe diaper recycling shouldn’t be part of the equation if the numbers in the city staff report are correct, that’s a significant caveat.
Because the fact is, we don’t yet know the true costs. The haulers are still revising them.
And, Brown has asserted that the program’s success has been understated. His claims should be investigated.
After all, the city has a vested interest in diaper recycling. It has invested almost a year of its time and at least $250,000 of its own money — and another $250,000 of the state’s — in the pilot program.
Therefore, on Tuesday the City Council should shelve the program, but it also should do its due diligence. It should thoroughly analyze the disputed data and negotiate the best prices with the haulers — and be prepared to reconsider diaper recycling when the final bids are in.
