In its fight to win the city’s lucrative solid-waste contracts, Blue Barrel Disposal circulated a list Tuesday comparing itself to Burrtec Waste Industries, which was recommended for the job by city staff earlier this week.
With the list, Blue Barrel attempts to demonstrate that it is offering as much or more than what Burrtec has promised the city.
But city officials said Wednesday that they disagreed with some of Blue Barrel’s assertions.
Blue Barrel circulated the list through the Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce on Tuesday to chamber members and officials at City Hall.
In its original proposal to the city, Blue Barrel, a subsidiary of Waste Management Inc., offered an alternative proposal called “Do It Now,” through which the company would implement a residential rate reduction on Jan. 1, 2004, rather than waiting until the new residential contract takes effect in April 2006.
“The ‘Do It Now’ proposal is a little misleading,” said Assistant City Manager Jill Fosselman. “Staff did not evaluate ‘Do It Now.’ We have negotiated the best and final offers with the haulers.”
Blue Barrel bases its self-comparison to Burrtec on the offers in its “Do It Now” proposal. However, in the actual proposal Blue Barrel signed, there is no provision to reduce residential fees in 2004, Fosselman said.
“In the signed contract they do not make that available,” she said.
Santa Clarita residents pay $22.13 a month for their trash service — among the highest rate in the state. In its proposal, Blue Barrel would cut that rate to $16.25 beginning in the first year of service.
The “Do It Now” proposal was an added feature to Blue Barrel’s proposal that the city did not specifically request when it circulated the trash franchises for a competitive bid. In exchange for the “Do It Now” plan, Blue Barrel sought a lengthier contract than the one being offered by the city.
A second unasked-for offer from Blue Barrel is a promise to collect waste from Santa Clarita schools at no cost.
Blue Barrel Manager Chris Fall said the company would charge the schools only for an internal disposal rate, which breaks down to about $250,000 in savings for the first year.
The reduced rate for the schools is included in Blue Barrel’s commercial contract, but was not part of the city’s original request.
Fosselman said she could not confirm the value of the reduced school rate.
“Schools are outside of the scope of the franchise agreement,” she said. “There is no way to quantify (that value).”
Fall argued that city staff should have evaluated Blue Barrel’s alternative proposal, and felt the company should be able to use added incentives as leverage against its competition.
For example, Fall said, a materials recovery facility, or MRF, was not included in the city’s request for proposals, but the city is taking it into consideration anyway.
Further, Fall said, it was the city and a consultant who removed the “Do It Now” proposal from consideration, not Blue Barrel.
The city’s request for proposals did not include a MRF. However, two of the finalists — Blue Barrel and Burrtec — offered to build MRFs, Fosselman said.
“Staff did not seek out the MRF,” she said, “they were offered as enhancements to proposal.”
q q q
On the comparison list, Blue Barrel states it would use new alternative-fuel vehicles to collect trash.
Both Burrtec and Consolidated Disposal Service included in their final contracts with the city a promise to use all-new alternative-fuel vehicles. In its signed proposal, Blue Barrel agrees to use alternative-fuel vehicles but does not specify they will be new.
“We have the full intent of having new alternative-fuel vehicles, but in order to ensure that we were in full compliance on alternative-fuel trucks, we wanted to be able to use existing alternative-fuel trucks (from) other districts until the new trucks could arrive as a resource,” Fall said.
“We would not use used alternative-fuel vehicles,” he said.
Similarly, Blue Barrel claims it would provide mixed-waste processing for the city’s commercial sector, where the hauler collects, sorts and processes the entire waste stream from commercial clients that tend to produce large volumes of recyclable material.
But Fosselman said that wasn’t included in Blue Barrel’s actual offer.
“I don’t believe that is accurate,” she said. “In the contracts signed by all three haulers, Burrtec is the only hauler that guaranteed to do that.”
Fall said Blue Barrel intends to provide commercial mixed-waste processing, even though it, too, is absent from Blue Barrel’s official proposal.
“We didn’t itemize it, but we will do it,” Fall said.
q q q
Burrtec Vice President Mike Arreguin criticized Blue Barrel for publishing the comparison list, calling it “inaccurate, incomplete” and “unfair.”
The city’s requests, Arreguin said, “are very to the point.”
“Haulers could add in or enhance their proposals, and haulers had special extras they added,” he said. “The schools (for example) were an extra, not a requirement.”
Arreguin said he understood that at the 11th hour, the competing haulers would be pulling out all the stops, but said he didn’t want to “get into a war ... with Waste Management because the staff didn’t support them in their recommendation.”
