ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Take a Stand and Hire Burrtec

It’s time for a change. The question is, does your City Council have the intestinal fortitude to make it?

I’m not so sure.

A parade of movers and shakers will converge upon council chambers tonight as the council considers whether to hire a new trash hauler or grant new contracts to the existing ones.

Council members will face an intimidating assortment of local leaders — and it will be a challenge for them to remember their duty to make the right decision for all taxpayers.

They can’t make this decision based on a straw poll of those attending the meeting, or based on fears of the decision’s impact on their next election, or based on the fact that one of the haulers spent a lot of money helping elect certain council members last year. They also shouldn’t make this a 5-0 vote just for the sake of appearing unified.

There. I think we’ve covered my concerns with each of the five council members.

I believe Marsha McLean and Frank Ferry — both of whom have received a great deal of campaign support from Blue Barrel (Waste Management) — would never in a million years vote for any other hauler. So Blue Barrel started this process with two votes locked up, only needing one more. If I’m proven wrong on that, I’ll gladly admit it.

That leaves Cameron Smyth, Laurene Weste and Bob Kellar. To them, I’d say: If you don’t have the courage to choose a hauler other than Blue Barrel if it means the best combination of service and price, what was the point of the bid process?

---

I regret I cannot attend tonight’s meeting, because this evening I will be helping to teach my 8-year-old son’s ice hockey team how to execute a neutral zone regroup. I look forward to seeing it on tape, though — because I expect there will be high drama.

No matter what, local taxpayers will save tens of millions of dollars over the life of the new contract. I am proud of this, because the council would not have put the contracts out to an open bidding process two years ago if this newspaper had not called attention to the problems with the existing trash service.

The problems have been in two main areas: Price and waste diversion.

On waste diversion, it’s important to remember the existing haulers have not done the job here since the franchises were established in 1991. They’ve had more than a decade in which to meet state mandates for diversion, and Santa Clarita has failed. Waste Management and Consolidated have provided good customer service — but they most certainly have not been effective when it comes to waste diversion.

That issue must weigh heavily. What is our best chance to achieve the diversion goals — the hauler(s) who haven’t done it for us so far, or a new one that would be contractually obligated to build a materials recovery facility and sell it to the city?

Then there’s price.

The council solves the price problem no matter what it does. Despite Waste Management’s statement to the council two years ago that it was not feasible to lower local trash rates, all three finalists, including Waste Management, offer rates significantly lower than what we pay now. Whatever the choice, this process has been a victory in terms of rates.

Putting aside the question of whether Waste Management “lied” to the city back then, the question now is, which is the best deal?

The city staff and the city’s consultant — the highly regarded Hilton Farnkopf & Hobson — believe Fontana-based Burrtec offers the best deal.

I feel I owe the city staff an apology: I have long felt the bid process was a foregone conclusion in favor of Waste Management and its local subsidiary, Blue Barrel. I see now that was not the case, at least with respect to the staff.

I still believe they erred in allowing Waste Management’s non-responsive bid to make the cut into the final round earlier this year. However, as best as I can tell, they have done their job in this final round of negotiations — without favor toward one hauler or another — and to their credit they have made what is likely to be an unpopular recommendation.

Doing the right thing can be that way sometimes.

The city staff has gone out on a limb in recommending Burrtec. The easiest thing for them to do would have been to recommend that the city stick with the existing haulers. It would have been a popular move. Instead, the staff and the consultant have recommended a newcomer based on their evidently sincere belief that it is the best option.

I respect that.

The staff has incurred the wrath of Blue Barrel, which has launched a publicity campaign accusing the staff of acting arbitrarily. That and several other claims Blue Barrel is making seem baseless. If Blue Barrel does happen to sway the council tonight, I’d love to be a fly on the wall the next time the staff and Blue Barrel get together for a meeting.

Blue Barrel’s “fact sheets” being distributed to local movers and shakers are misleading at the very least. All through this process, Blue Barrel has employed tactics that appear designed to tilt the playing field, and I can’t say I blame them for trying: They came in with an insanely low-ball number on residential service and a bid that essentially was non-responsive to the city’s request for proposals when it came to waste diversion. They knew all they had to do was make it to the final round in order to do the “real” negotiating. (Note that Blue Barrel’s initial residential rate was $14.75 before the field of contenders was narrowed to the three finalists, and it is the only one that changed its rate in the final round of negotiations, jumping to $16.25.)

They’re trying something similar now. They are trying to add factors into the mix that aren’t at all contained in the contracts that have been negotiated. Those misleading factors will be hurled at the council dais tonight by the many local supporters of Blue Barrel.

Regardless, the council is obligated to consider only those factors contained in the contracts, and to choose the best option for all taxpayers — not just the one that would be most popular on the rubber chicken circuit.

We should expect tonight to hear from people whose favorite charities benefit from Blue Barrel’s generosity — and our council has to remember that redistributing money to charities is not the purpose of trash franchises. (Besides, any business that wants to do well in this town will participate with the many good local causes we have here.)

The non-profits will be joined by the for-profits in support of Blue Barrel, too.

Blue Barrel’s manager — a likeable guy named Chris Fall — is on the chamber of commerce’s board of directors. While the chamber has not “officially” taken a stand on the issue, we can expect local movers and shakers to make a show of force tonight in favor of Blue Barrel. The hauler has solicited their support and armed them with some misleading “clarifications,” which essentially suggest residents and the council should support Blue Barrel based not on its contract, but on promises that are nowhere to be found in the contract.

Considering that, I hope the city staff is prepared tonight to withstand some heat — and to be armed with the information to respond, and steer the debate toward what’s actually in the contract, not what Blue Barrel wishes to throw into the mix at the 11th hour, now that all three contracts have been released publicly. The council cannot attempt to renegotiate a $100 million-plus deal from the dais, and essentially trash this lengthy process in which the staff and consultant have followed the rules.

It is what it is.

The council members, too, must stay on task — and consider only the contracts that are before them.

Blue Barrel’s “Do it Now” plan? Not part of the contract. And, they’d only “do it now” if they got an extra three years tacked onto the deal — and even then, they’d only “do it now” if they got both the residential and commercial contracts.

Advice to the council: It’s not fair play. If you’re going to negotiate a longer-term deal with them at this late stage, then you’d better reopen the bid process and do the same with the other haulers, or prepare yourself for the inevitable lawsuit. That could get expensive.

It will be no easy task for the council to award the contract to Burrtec. The mood in council chambers will heavily favor Blue Barrel, based on the personal loyalty of some of our community’s most prominent citizens.

It will take nerve for council members to stand up to that influential audience.

Do they have it?

Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor.

← Back to 2003

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:3270.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,499 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [managing editor]
  • text:valley_names [2 distinct/2 mentions: Santa Clarita, City Council]
  • text:valley_elected_official “Cameron Smyth”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0