Ten Southland women’s shelters, including the Domestic Violence Center of Santa Clarita, have been dropped from a sexual discrimination lawsuit filed in June by a men’s rights activist.
Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Jon Mayeda ruled Friday that the shelters offer protected, lawful programs.
“I think it was the wrong (institution to) attack,” said Marci Fukuroda, staff attorney at the California Women’s Law Center.
Eldon Blumhorst, a member of the men’s rights group National Coalition of Free Men, accused 10 women’s shelters in Southern California of discriminating against him when he called them for assistance and they refused to offer him aid.
The man claimed in his lawsuit that he called the women’s shelters and told them he had been battered. He said they turned him away because he was a man.
Blumhorst based his legal attack on a section in California law which states that no state-funded program may discriminate against anyone on the basis of race, national origin, ethnic group, religion, age, sex, color or disability. All of the shelters named in the lawsuit were state-funded under the California Battered Women Shelter Program, created in 1994.
But another section of the law clarifies that the prohibition against discrimination cannot be misinterpreted to jeopardize lawful programs designed to benefit the disabled, aged, minorities or women — such as a shelter for abused women. Under this section, the lawsuit against the shelters was dismissed and cannot be appealed, Fukuroda said.
“I thought (the lawsuit) was frivolous,” said Dr. Kathy Mathis, executive director of the Domestic Violence Center of Santa Clarita. “I would like to see (Blumhorst) put his money into providing the services (to men) instead of suing agencies for providing the services they provide.”
Mathis said the lawsuit expended resources that could have been used by the shelters to provide help to women.
“Let’s put it this way: Lawsuits are never free,” she said.
Blumhorst recently amended his complaint to include the county of Los Angeles and the state of California. A court hearing will be held Oct. 21 on the challenge to the county and state, Fukuroda said.
