The dedicated volunteers and staff at the Domestic Violence Center of Santa Clarita can breathe a little easier today. On Friday a judge threw out a ludicrous lawsuit which, had it succeeded, could have jeopardized the center’s ability to help battered women.
The complaint, filed in June by a member of a men’s rights organization — yes, there is such a thing — alleged that Santa Clarita’s battered women’s shelter and nine similar shelters throughout Southern California discriminated against him by refusing to come to his aid.
The man, one Eldon Blumhorst, claimed to have called the 10 shelters, claiming to be a victim of domestic violence and wanting help. Each shelter told him they couldn’t do anything because he is male.
Blumhorst sued on grounds that the 10 shelters receive some of their financial support from the state, and California law prohibits state-funded programs from discriminating on the basis of race, ethnicity, color, national origin, ethnicity, religion, age, disability — or gender.
On Friday a Superior Court judge dismissed the shelters from the complaint, citing another section of the same law clarifying that it can’t be misinterpreted to rule out programs designed specifically to help the disabled, aged, minorities — or women.
While we do sympathize with male victims of domestic violence — yes, there is such a thing — Blumhorst was wrong to target individual, private, non-profit shelters that choose to help women, just as a women’s rights activist would be wrong to attack a shelter set up by Blumhorst that chooses to help men.
Which might be a better way for Blumhorst to exert himself.
