When critics have talked about Santa Clarita being a “company town” over the years, they’ve usually referred to The Newhall Land and Farming Co., the valley’s largest developer.
But watching our City Council in action Thursday night, it was difficult not to think of a different company as the one leading our local leaders around by their noses.
It’s the worst-kept secret among local political observers: Waste Management Inc., the 5-ton monkey of trash haulers, and its subsidiary, Blue Barrel Disposal, has at least a couple of your City Council members comfortably under its thumb.
That’s not just bananas we’re smelling.
The masses in Santa Clarita don’t give a rat’s patoot, which is part of the reason Santa Clarita, in some ways, is a microcosm of everything wrong with American politics. Perhaps if Santa Claritans cared about it, things might change. But you don’t hold your local politicians accountable — you don’t even vote — so the game of money and politics is played by their rules, rather than the ideal.
An update for those not paying attention: Two-plus years ago, this newspaper called attention to the fact that the rates under the city’s trash franchises were exorbitantly high, among the highest in Southern California, in part due to inflated figures representing the costs for haulers to dump trash at area landfills.
This newspaper further reported that, despite the city’s chest-puffing claims of being environmentally conscious, its waste diversion rates were below those mandated by state law — dismally so.
In other words, you were paying too much to have too little accomplished.
It took a great deal of arm-twisting and ranting on the opinion pages, but we finally got a City Council majority to submit the trash franchises to an open bidding process, rather than simply renewing the contracts held by Blue Barrel and Consolidated Disposal Services. Make no mistake: They wouldn’t have gone to bid without the pressure applied by The Signal. That’s not just bragging. It’s fact.
It wasn’t popular among the local power elite, which has viewed Blue Barrel as a cash cow for local charities. Blue Barrel indeed has been an outstanding corporate citizen, simply due to the fact that it can afford to. When there’s an extra quarter-million dollars leaving town for Waste Management’s Houston headquarters every month or two, you can afford to be generous. That wouldn’t be a problem at all except for the fact that the trash haulers had city franchises that are essentially government-guaranteed monopolies.
So they went to bid. And here we are, two years later, with push finally coming to shove. The bids are in, and the city staff has carefully negotiated residential and commercial contracts with each of three haulers — the two existing ones and a newcomer, Fontana-based Burrtec.
Lo and behold, all three companies offer improved services and much lower rates than the ones under the old contract, despite Blue Barrel’s insistence two years ago that such a thing could not be done.
Further, the staff determines that Burrtec — not the locally favored Blue Barrel — offers the best combination of service, price and the capability of meeting state diversion requirements.
Let’s just say that didn’t sit well with the local power elite.
Blue Barrel pulled out all the stops this week, adding new things to its proposal and touting features that were nowhere to be found in the company’s proposed contract with the city.
The company made a great deal of hay out of its offer to provide “free” service to local schools, without providing detailed cost and savings figures. (And, the service wouldn’t be “free” — it would be deeply discounted, as the schools would still have to pay costs like landfill fees.) Regardless, that was enough to convince local school leaders to testify in favor of Blue Barrel at Thursday night’s City Council meeting.
Support from school officials, local business leaders and the rubber chicken circuit, the movers and shakers who rely on Blue Barrel’s charitable ways — it’s all part of the company’s arsenal when it goes to City Hall in pursuit of a new contract.
Those things, plus the company’s direct influence on your City Council.
Council members Frank Ferry and Marsha McLean received a great deal of financial support from Waste Management/Blue Barrel in last year’s election. Tens of thousands of dollars’ worth. The result has been the closest thing you can get to a guarantee that neither Ferry nor McLean will ever vote for a trash franchise option that does not somehow favor Blue Barrel. That leaves the trash giant needing just one vote.
I like our mayor a lot. I consider Cameron Smyth a friend, and I hope it’s mutual, and remains so even after what I am about to say.
I’m sure I’ve ticked him off more than once through this process, especially when I imply that he can’t help but think of his political future when these matters come before the council. Cameron adamantly says he’s looking for the best deal and nothing but the best deal, regardless of what it may mean when his next election comes around. Yet, there’s no getting around the fact that politically savvy and influential people are working on him.
He is in the early stages of a very promising political career. Cameron has the looks, the lineage, the charisma and the smarts to go far as an elected official. It’s no secret, and don’t think for a second there aren’t sharp people leaning on him, pushing him one way or another, and dangling political carrots in front of his nose. A young politician in such a position is walking through a minefield, no matter what he does.
Then there are Laurene Weste and Bob Kellar.
Weste has been on the right side of the trash issue all along. She’s been wrong on other things, and I have said so. But on this one, she’s the council member who has made the most sense.
Kellar showed great political courage a couple of years ago when he was the swing vote to send the trash contracts out to bid. I know he has it in him to do the right thing on any given vote, but truth be told, from what I saw of Thursday night’s meeting (I caught the latter portions of it via webcast, which was terrific), and from what I read about the meeting, I can’t figure Bob on this one.
At some level, I think each of the five does have the best interests of Santa Clarita taxpayers in mind — including Ferry and McLean, who are so closely linked to Blue Barrel as to make their votes a foregone conclusion. Some council members want the best deal; others clearly want only the best deal that involves Blue Barrel.
That played out on Thursday night.
Desperate attempts were made to poke holes in the staff recommendation. Angles were explored. Maneuvers were made.
The end result?
Smyth proposed an alternative in which the staff would be directed to spend 30 days negotiating with Blue Barrel for a revised residential deal and with Burrtec for a revised commercial deal — which could lead to a split arrangement, rather than having both franchises go to one hauler. The council voted 4-1, with Kellar dissenting, in favor of the mayor’s motion.
You know what? That just may get us a better deal. In 30 days, we could be better off than we would have been if the staff recommendation had been approved. That, of course, is a maybe. A big one. But Thursday night’s decision could have a good outcome. There is one thing it does not change, though, and I’ll illustrate it with a hypothetical scenario that will ring true with anyone who watches your City Council in action.
Suppose for a moment that all of the circumstances were the same: One hauler was recommended by the staff because of its best overall value after a months-long negotiation process. The other hauler did not get the recommendation, but after the staff report came out, it applied political pressure and executed all sorts of transparent 11th-hour maneuvers to make its proposal seem more attractive.
Now switch the names.
If the roles were reversed, and it were Blue Barrel that were deemed by the staff to be the best combination of service, price and waste diversion, does anyone think for a nanosecond that we would have seen anything but a 5-0 vote Thursday night in favor of giving the whole $100-million deal to Blue Barrel?
Of course not.
And that, ladies and gentlemen, is what’s wrong with your city government.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
