Before Tuesday’s recall election, there was no small amount of debate over the rules of the election and what its outcome might truly mean.
For example: If Gray Davis lost his bid to remain governor, but drew a higher percentage of the vote than his replacement, there were those who said such an outcome would have demonstrated the inherent unfairness of the recall rules.
True enough, the recall rules have room for improvement. Those who side with Davis have a point. Only one adult Californian — Davis — was expressly prohibited from being on the list of candidates to be the new governor.
Further, that list contained 135 names, making it seem quite possible, even likely, that the person elected to replace the governor could win while actually earning fewer votes than Davis. Since the race would be decided on a plurality — the candidate with the most votes wins, without necessarily needing more than 50 percent — it was conceivable that a relatively low percentage of voters would actually choose the next governor.
Can anyone say, “run-off”?
As the early numbers rolled in Tuesday night, it became clear that California, which has endured many political misfortunes in the past year, finally has been fortunate in at least one regard:
We won’t be having that debate.
With just over 20 percent of the precincts reporting, Davis had pulled approximately 44 percent of the vote in his failed bid to remain governor. And at the top of the 135-candidate heap was California’s next governor, action film star Arnold Schwarzenegger, with just over 50 percent of the vote.
In other words, Schwarzenegger pulled a greater percentage of a vote split among 135 candidates than Davis did from a ballot question with just two options: “Yes” or “No” as to whether he should be recalled.
Schwarzenegger’s nearest opponent was Democrat Cruz Bustamante, with approximately 30 percent.
If those numbers hold — and at press time, it appeared they would — it’s a strong statement. If that’s not a mandate, it’s difficult to imagine what is.
It means Californians won’t be engaged in the debate over the recall rules and who “really” should have won; the choice was clear.
For Schwarzenegger, the work is only beginning. California faces a deep political and economic morass, and digging out will be more difficult than any challenge faced by his characters on the silver screen.
However, at least he will be able to face that challenge with the benefit of a clear, undisputable victory.
