If it looks like a recyclable sorting facility, it must be a recycling sorting facility.
The city’s Planning Commission made that decision Tuesday, ruling that operations at a Canyon Country business classify it as such a facility, also known as a materials recovery facility, or a MRF.
“It’s quacking like a duck,” said Commissioner Tim Burkhart.
The decision also adds to the city’s development code for the first time a definition for MRFs in the city of Santa Clarita.
The Commission voted 4-1 to classify Rent-A-Bin as a MRF, with Commissioner Rick Winsman dissenting.
The Planning Commission based its decision partially on a definition from the state Integrated Waste Management Board, which defines a MRF as “a permitted solid waste facility where solid wastes or recyclable materials are sorted or separated, by hand or by use of machinery, for the purposes of recycling or composting.”
According to the city staff report, Rent-A-Bin receives solid waste, sorts the material and then transports it for recycling or disposal.
But representatives for Rent-A-Bin maintained that the business does not meet the state definition for a MRF, which would require the company to undergo a costly and more extensive permit process.
“The state agency that defines what a MRF is says this is not a MRF,” said Rent-A-Bin’s representative and attorney Hunt Braly. “We disagree on the definition of a MRF, and we feel there hasn’t been enough work done on this.”
Braly said it should be classified as an “outdoor dual collection lot.” The business also processes greenwaste and keeps collection trucks and bins as accessory, or additional, uses.
Planning Manager Vince Bertoni told the commissioners they had to ask themselves, “If it’s not a MRF, than what is it?”
An outdoor dual collect lot, according to the staff report, is a low intensity use involving “a limited number of trucks delivering a significant amount of recyclables or a citizen delivering a small amount.” Waste materials are already separated, and no processing occurs at the site, the report states.
City officials argued that Rent-A-Bin does not meet the state’s definition of a recycling center, which “shall only receive material that has been separated for reuse prior to receipt.”
A conditional use permit is needed to operate a MRF. Braly argued that because of the types of operations at Rent-A-Bin, the business only needs a minor use permit.
A city staff report states that a MRF “is an intensive use,” that carries many significant impacts.
Minor use permits allow use types that tend to have fewer local impacts. Conditional use permits are issued to businesses that carry a wide range of impacts that affect a larger area.
Further, conditional use permits require extensive public noticing, a public hearing, and are more time-consuming and costly for the applicant.
The Planning Commission’s decision means Rent-A-Bin’s owners will now have to begin the process of applying for a conditional use permit to operate the MRF.
