“It is quite impossible to keep pace with all the new incarnations of women in war-time - 'bus-conductress, ticket-collector, lift-girl, club waitress, post-woman, bank clerk, motor-driver, farm-laborer, guide, munition maker.” — Punch Magazine, June 1916
Dress rehearsals are not just for actors, dancers and musicians. In preparation for the upcoming College of the Canyons 2003 Scholarly Presentation, Patty Robinson, Ph.d, held a “dress rehearsal” for an audience of colleagues to ensure her presentation skills would be well-honed for the “real thing” on Wednesday. Members of COC’s Scholarly Presentation Panel listened as Robinson, a COC Sociology Professor, rehearsed her presentation of her lecture on an underexplored aspect of historical feminism in America.
“Feminists, Federations, and ‘Farmerettes’”: The Mobilization of the Woman’s Land Army of World War I,” is the subject of Robinson’s doctoral dissertation in which she introduces a ‘revisionist’ interpretation of early American feminism.
According to Robinson, many people think only of the Suffragettes in relation to the feminist movements of the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Yet, as history is reexamined, the Suffragettes were running alongside another significant movement, the “Club Women’s Movement.” This parallel collaboration of women was equally vigorous in their efforts to empower women, yet with an entirely different approach. “Club Women” were ladies of leisure, married to wealthy men and confined predefined traditional feminine roles. Unlike the Suffragettes, these women embraced the idea of “feminine domesticity.”
“I found it so incredibly fascinating, especially since it was contradicting a lot of history that I had been taught,”said Robinson. “We knew a lot about the Suffragettes but not the Club Movement.”
The Club Women viewed themselves as feminists who could attain a more powerful position by using the confines of their “gender spheres” of motherhood, housekeeping and subservience as a vehicle. Club Women did not believe that earning the right to vote was the best way to bring about change; not only did they not want the law to be changed, they were opposed to women having the right to vote. The movement was coupled with the rise of the industrial revolution which yielded more free time for women to begin to mobilize and question the status quo on their world.
While the beliefs and approaches of the Suffragettes and the Club Women were nearly polarized, they shared a mission of expanding women’s influence in society.
According to Robinson, the Club Women’s movement was largely ignored due to the fact that the Club Women worked largely within their ‘gender spheres’, meaning that they continued to cherish and embrace their traditional subservient roles.
“Few sociologists have looked at this topic,” said Robinson. “It has been primarily explored by historians.”
Among the oldest women’s club in the nation is The New England Women’s Club which held its first meeting in 1868. The purpose of the club was to provide a place for women to meet outside their homes, which in and of itself was a radical notion during that time. The meetings offered new knowledge and inspiration to women for their work at in and outside the home and united their efforts to support social causes. Meetings included guest speakers lecturing on subjects spanning literature, history, art and music as well as significant social issues.
The momentum of this movement culminated in the wide participation of Club Women in the war effort as World War I broke out. The home economic skills of the Club Women made them invaluable replacements to fill in for many positions abandoned the men who were called to service. Among them were the “farmerettes," a division of the national Women’s Land Army, who replaced farm help when men went off to war.
Robinson’s presentation was well-received — the only drawback being the difficulty of conveying decades worth of interesting information in a mere 45 minutes. Suggestions for Robinson’s presentation from the Scholarly Presentation Committee included paring down extensive list of projects undertaken by the Club Woman as well as summarizing the presentation’s objectives more concisely.
While the presentation takes place in an academic setting, the lecture is designed to be entertaining and interesting to the general public. A slide show depicting a fascinating documentation of women from all sectors of the late 19th and early 20th centuries runs concurrently with the lecture.
Robinson’s presentation will be held on Wednesday, Nov. 5 from 4-5 p.m. and will be followed by a reception. There is no fee for admission however seating is limited. Call the COC Foundation for reservations and tickets for complimentary parking, 362-3493.
