A local attorney has filed three motions in hopes a judge will toss out a lawsuit against tree sitter John Quigley.
Documents filed by Anthony D. Zinnanti, Quigley’s attorney, seek to convince Superior Court Judge John P. Shook to dismiss a civil suit filed by developer John Laing Homes when Quigley sat in an oak tree in Pico Canyon for 71 days to protest its planned removal.
Zinnanti is arguing that the trespassing case should be dismissed because:
• John Laing Homes never requested monetary damages from Quigley.
“All they ever asked for was an order to take John out of the tree and be kept out of tree,” Zinnanti said. “John has never expressed interest in returning to the tree. The lawsuit is defective.”
• No evidence of damages should be heard in court, because Laing forgot to ask for damages.
“They forgot to ask for money, so any monetary issues are irrelevant and ought to be kicked out of evidence,” Zinnanti said. “This goes hand-in-hand with the first motion. There is nothing to go to trial about.”
• The evidence — the Old Glory oak tree itself — would be destroyed or, in legal terms, “spoliated,” if it were moved a quarter-mile down the road from its original location. Laing has started the lengthy process of moving the tree to a future park.
The tree’s original location relative to Pico Canyon Road could become important to determining whether Quigley actually trespassed, Zinnanti suggested.
“I want the scene preserved ... in the event the judge grants my motion, (to) have jury see location of where alleged trespass took place,” he said. “The proximity of the tree to the road is relevant to whether John actually trespassed, and if so, whether it was a matter of Laing’s consent.”
Bill Rattazzi, regional president of John Laing Homes, said he would not comment on ongoing litigation.
A court hearing has been scheduled for Nov. 24.
Zinnanti said he is ready for the possibility of a long, drawn-out battle.
“Judge Shook is going to force people to move into their respective positions,” Zinnanti said. “If they (Laing) fight to keep the lawsuit alive, I know they’re serious about monetary judgment against John. They will have one hell of a fight on their hands. I’m serious about the scene where the alleged incident took place.”
Laing has estimated it will have cost more than $1 million to preserve and move Old Glory to its new location, including around-the-clock security, legal fees and moving expenses.
