Be honest: How many of you would think a piece of property a half-mile from your front door would be an appropriate place for a homeless shelter?
We’re betting most people would say, even if they believe a homeless shelter is something necessary and noble, that they would rather not have it located right down the street from their own homes.
And that is understandable. It’s all too easy to condemn those who would rather not live down the street from the local homeless shelter — especially if you happen to live on the other side of town.
Many Santa Claritans are fortunate enough to own their homes, and knowing that there are homeless here who truly need assistance reminds homeowners of just how fortunate they really are. That doesn’t change the fact that a person’s home is, typically, the biggest investment they ever make. It is something in which the owner takes pride, and something whose value the owner wishes to protect.
Hence, it’s understandable to see the debate over where the Santa Clarita homeless shelter should be located, and for how long.
The City Council did the right thing this week, voting 4-1 to grant a one-year agreement for the non-profit Santa Clarita Community Development Corp. to operate the seasonal winter shelter in the parking lot of the Via Princessa Metrolink station.
In doing so, the council also informed the CDC that it needs to find a new location after this winter — in other words, as Councilwoman Laurene Weste put it, “One year means one year.”
The CDC had sought a five-year lease for the site, which would have saved the charitable organization money because it could have arranged for more semi-permanent structures, rather than tents.
Providing a seasonal shelter for the homeless is simply the humane thing to do. In places like Santa Clarita, the hard part is finding a place to provide that shelter without causing undue impacts on the rest of the citizenry. It may seem insensitive, but the cold hard truth is that a homeless shelter could be viewed as a deterrent for potential home buyers or shoppers.
That means the ideal location would have a reasonable cushion from residential and retail areas. Is there such a place in Santa Clarita?
Councilman Frank Ferry stepped to the plate and offered to help find it on Tuesday night, vowing to assemble a group of local leaders to find a place for the homeless shelter to operate after this one-year deal expires. Ferry is to be commended for the pledge, and we wish him luck — it’s a tall order.
Further, we disagree with the vote Councilman Bob Kellar cast in dissent Tuesday night — and we don’t agree with his statement that equates having a homeless shelter with perpetuating a general feeling of discomfort among residents on city streets. That has proven to be false in the shelter’s past years of operation.
However, we also disagree with those who are jumping all over Kellar for his statement that he “would have had a cow” if the shelter was proposed for his neighborhood. Unlike some who stake out the moral high ground — and can do so with ease because the shelter isn’t in their neighborhoods — the councilman is just being honest.
After all. How would you react if they wanted to put the homeless shelter in your neighborhood?
Therein lies the challenge.
