A federal judge has removed an obstacle to the proposed Cemex gravel mine in Soledad Canyon.
U.S. District Senior Judge Robert Takasugi ruled Thursday that the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service followed federal laws to protect an endangered fish found primarily in the Santa Clara River.
The federal agency was sued in January 2002 by two environmental groups, the Center for Biological Diversity and Friends of the Santa Clara River, for failing to designate a “critical habitat” for the unarmored threespine stickleback, a fish that was added in 1970 to the federal endangered species list.
The lawsuit stemmed from the Bureau of Land Management’s issuance of permits that would allow Mexican cement giant Cemex to extract 78 million tons of sand and gravel in eastern Canyon Country over 20 years.
The city of Santa Clarita has spent millions to fight the mine, arguing, among other things, that it would irreversibly damage the river and its habitat — including that of the stickleback and other rare species such as the southwestern arroyo toad and the California gnatcatcher, a bird.
Environmentalists argued that the federal agencies should have established a critical habitat for the fish in 1981. Defined under the 1973 Endangered Species Act, a critical habitat is an area that is considered a safe haven for the recovery of a threatened or endangered species.
The Wildlife Service proposed a 30-mile-long habitat along the Santa Clara River and San Francisquito Creek but never implemented the plan.
Takasugi sided with the federal agencies and Cemex, which intervened as a codefendant in the case.
He ruled that the environmental groups based their arguments on state laws that were more restrictive than comparable federal laws.
Although the federal Endangered Species Act allows for state laws to be more restrictive, that “does not render the BLM’s issuance of permits to Cemex not otherwise lawful,” he ruled.
“To read it otherwise would require federal agencies to comply with the more restrictive state law and would, thereby, result in the preemption of federal law by state law,” Takasugi ruled. “However, this does not mean that Cemex is exempt from complying with state law.”
Cemex spokesman Brian Mastin said the company was pleased that the issue had been resolved.
“We attempted to do everything in accordance with all laws,” he said.
Lynne Plambeck, a Friends of the Santa Clara River board member, was discouraged.
“It’s too bad the judge didn’t agree with us,” Plambeck said. “I hope the Friends will appeal it. Sometimes a three-judge panel will see things differently.”
CBD attorney Brent Plater said his organization has not yet decided to appeal what he called the judge’s “paltry ruling,” which, he contends, is inconsistent with the Endangered Species Act.
The ruling concludes only one of three lawsuits involving Cemex’s Soledad Canyon mining project. The company is in negotiations to settle a lawsuit it filed against the county of Los Angeles, as well as a suit filed against Cemex by the city of Santa Clarita.
Jeffrey Lambert, the former city planning director who remains in charge of the city’s Cemex fight as a consultant, said the ruling will not have a significant impact on the city’s lawsuit.
“Our lawsuit has 17 causes of action,” Lambert said. “Theirs had three, all about the stickleback.”
The city’s complaint names several other threatened and endangered species that could be harmed by the mine, he said.
