It’s on to the Appellate Court, officials said, as a judge dismissed a complaint against a developer filed more than a year ago, but did not throw out a libel and trespassing case against an environmental group Monday.
The Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment filed suit against John Laing Homes Nov. 20, 2002 for fraud, breach of contract, unfair business practices and breach of covenant of good faith and fair dealing.
The lawsuit contends that Laing Homes reneged on a 1999 good faith agreement to redesign Pico Canyon Road in an effort to save a centuries-old oak, known back then as Oak Tree No. 419.
But Superior Court Judge John P. Shook, the same judge who derailed environmentalists’ plan to save the tree now commonly known as Old Glory by ordering tree sitter John Quigley from the tree Jan. 10, said Monday there was no need for SCOPE, who was represented Monday by Attorney Donald Ricketts, to continue it’s suit against the developer.
“It seems to me that this case is essentially over,” Shook said.
Laing Homes, who was represented by Greg Regier and Karen Fine, accused SCOPE Monday of not providing information the developer needed for evidence.
“We can’t file a motion for evidence we can’t obtain,” said Karen Fine. “And we couldn’t bring a motion to a party that doesn’t have counsel.”
But SCOPE President Lynne Plambeck said those allegations were without merit.
“They have my number. They could have contacted me,” she said.
Shook’s decision outraged Plambeck, who said the group will now get ready for an appeal.
“How can (Shook) make a decision like that,” Plambeck said. “They (Laing Homes) committed fraud. Shook ruled in a manner that will not be accepted by the appellate court. This is not justice.”
The two parties, and Quigley, are scheduled to be back in court Dec. 4 for a status conference on the two motions that were continued.
