Suppose a judge were to rule that your city should have no role in a legal battle over a massive development proposed for territory just outside city boundaries, and the ruling would be made on the grounds that the city has no interest in the issue because the project would be outside city limits.
It’s ludicrous, right?
Well, it happened.
U.S. District Court Judge Dickran Tevrizan has ruled that the city of Santa Clarita cannot be involved in the legal battle over whether a subsidiary of Cemex should be allowed to develop a massive sand and gravel mine on Santa Clarita’s eastern doorstep.
Tevrizan’s rationale, says City Attorney Carl Newton, is that the city has no interest in the project because it’s outside city boundaries.
Understandably, the City Council decided on Tuesday night to appeal the ruling.
While it’s true that the city has no jurisdiction over the proposed 460-acre mine site, it’s also true that no municipality will be more affected by the mine if it is developed as planned.
In the two-decade life of the mine, it is planned that 56 million tons of concrete aggregate will be mined from the Soledad Canyon site.
The mine’s projected impacts are substantial, and they directly apply to the territory within city limits: Santa Clarita residents will breathe the air that will be clouded by the mine’s blasting, Santa Clarita residents will deal with the truck traffic on local streets and freeways, and Santa Clarita residents will have legitimate concerns about the impact the mine could have on the quality and quantity of our local underground water supply.
If any entity should have the right to object to the Cemex mine, it’s Santa Clarita. The same could be said about any major development — residential, commercial or industrial — that occurs right outside a city’s borders but will have significant potential negative impacts on that city.
The judge’s decision to block the city from participating in the Cemex court case is a cement-headed ruling, and the city is right in deciding to appeal.
