With the trash franchises out of the way, the city is putting the squeeze on the cable television operators by suing Time Warner for what it says are past-due franchise fees.
The approach underscores the difference between the trash and cable franchises.
The city had to be prodded and cajoled to put its trash franchises to bid, in part because of the friendly rapport between city officials and the local trash company representatives. It’s a different situation with the cable companies. The two franchised operators, Time Warner and Comcast, are more reticent. They don’t grease palms in city elections. They don’t need to.
While the city can cut whatever trash deal it wants with the hauler of its choice, it doesn’t enjoy that luxury with cable television. Federal law prohibits the city from kicking out cable television companies except in extreme circumstances.
So don’t expect the cable franchise renewal process to be anything like what we just went through with trash.
With cable, the city doesn’t have a very big stick to wield. What gives the city the ability to regulate the cable companies at all is the infrastructure. Cable television is transmitted through cable lines that run under the streets in the public right-of-way, which the city controls. For this, the city collects franchise fees in the form of 5 percent of your cable bill.
The cable franchises are going through the renewal process right now. The city is pushing for better, more responsive customer service, and it wants the operators to put at least as many resources — money and personnel — into the Santa Clarita Valley’s community access television station (Channel 20) as they have done in the past.
From a legal standpoint, the city’s attempt to recover what it considers to be its due from Time Warner Cable is a separate issue. Maybe the city just discovered the billing discrepancy. But from a practical standpoint, the lawsuit could become a deal point — a stick the city wouldn’t otherwise have — as the cable franchises are renegotiated.
If it’s a tactic, we hope it will work. But what we really hope is that the cable companies will act on the city’s requests to provide better customer service and help it beef up the local television station.
You’d think those things would be in Comcast and Time Warner Cable’s best interest, if they want to differentiate themselves from satellite — which isn’t franchised, isn’t required provide Santa Clarita television coverage, and doesn’t pay any fees to the city.
There is something more that the city should consider during this franchise renewal process.
The city currently puts its 5-percent cable television royalties into the city’s general fund. But just like the state car tax should go for road improvements, the city should dedicate some of its cable television fees to improving and broadening the programming on the valley’s only local television station — the one it requires the operators to subsidize.
It would show good faith and might provide the leverage needed to turn Channel 20 into a full-service television station for Santa Clarita residents.
