In the month of December, one of the most frequent topics of water cooler discussion has nothing to do with the stock market or international relations or even celebrities and reality TV.
It’s college football: Which teams are going to which bowls, who will contend for the national title, what are the point spreads — all of these questions draw our attention amid the holiday atmosphere.
It’s part of the grand diversion that is December.
And here in America, we don’t like ties, nor do we like ambiguity. We like to crown champions. We like for there to be a clear-cut winner.
That desire is not satisfied in college football. And it has become clear that the BCS — the Bowl Championship Series — does not work.
This discussion occurs every year, as a top team is inevitably left out of the BCS championship game mix. In fact, this year marks the third time in the past four seasons that a team ranked among the top two in the college football polls is being excluded from the BCS title game, which this year is the Sugar Bowl.
It just so happens that, this year, the team being excluded is a Los Angeles team, the University of Southern California.
The record shall reflect that The Signal’s official position on college football in the Southern California region is to favor UCLA.
This is due to a strong personal loyalty on the part of a key member of The Signal’s management team, and also due to the fact that several high-profile Santa Clarita Valley high school graduates are Bruins.
So, we have no strong allegiance to USC, and typically only have a rooting interest for the Trojans if UCLA is completely out of the picture, and even then, it’s questionable.
But to put it quite simply, USC got rooked.
The Trojans, with just one loss earlier in the season and a strong finish that resulted in a No. 1 ranking in both top polls, deserve to be in the college football national championship game.
Instead, USC will play Michigan in the Rose Bowl — a fate that, admittedly, just may be the best consolation prize ever.
However, the BCS title game will feature LSU and Oklahoma, which occupied the top spot in the polls until an embarrassing 35-7 conference championship loss Saturday to Kansas State.
Which is the best team in college football? If USC wins the Rose Bowl, it will have a legitimate claim to that title, but will have been denied by the BCS formula — a complicated blending of polls, computer rankings, schedule strength and, we imagine, assorted aspects of witchcraft.
The BCS was designed to prevent just such a scenario, an unsatisfying split of the national title. But when an 11-1 team finishes at the top of the polls and is not given an opportunity to play for the title on the field, something is terribly amiss.
Yes, we will join those who are raising the cry for a better system — perhaps a brief playoff, with No. 1 vs. No. 4, No. 2 vs. No. 3, and the winners playing for all the marbles. Obviously there will always be debate so long as votes and computers determine rankings, but we’d much rather argue about who’s No. 6 or No. 7 than who’s No. 1.
The BCS does not work. It’s time for a change.
