I expect your City Council tonight to approve a trash franchise contract — or contracts — that save you $30 million or so over the seven-year life of the deal.
This would not have happened if this newspaper hadn’t blown the whistle on the raw deal Santa Clarita was getting on trash more than two years ago. As a result of pressure from The Signal — and make no mistake, it wouldn’t have happened otherwise — your City Council put the trash franchises out to an open bid process.
The result you will likely see is part foregone conclusion, part happy ending. The happy ending is the $30 million in cost cuts. The foregone conclusion? The council may “split the baby,” as they say, and give the commercial franchise to a newcomer, but it’s a virtual lock that the most lucrative contract — residential — will go to Waste Management Inc., parent company of Blue Barrel.
Over the past couple of years WMI has cajoled, schmoozed, and, yes, intimidated in order to achieve this result. It has spent tens of thousands of dollars on City Council candidates’ campaigns and most certainly will do so again. Even if the best deal did not involve WMI, you can bet your council couldn’t muster a three-vote majority to boot the hauler out of town.
That said, it looks as if the best deal — at least the best one on the table right now — includes Waste Management.
The council should take it — or, if council members believe there may be more gains to be made, keep grinding.
WMI’s residential rates have dropped dramatically through the bid process, and if this contract is approved, we can feel confident that, at last, Santa Clarita will no longer be getting fleeced on trash.
One hauler or two? In some ways, I like the idea of granting the entire contract to one hauler. It seems to make sense from state reporting standpoints, and in terms of ease in keeping the hauler accountable. In other ways, I like the split-franchise idea because it keeps more than one hauler in town, increasing the odds of a truly competitive bid process when we do this all over again in seven years. Either way, we get a better deal.
And either way, this story will continue to evolve. Signal City Editor Leon Worden summed it up well in Wednesday’s paper: Santa Claritans may have grounds for a class action lawsuit. Even if Waste Management gets the lion’s share of the new contract, there’s still the possibility that Santa Claritans could recoup the “extra” money that left our economy over the past decade or so.
You see, the city’s existing trash rates were set based on false information about the haulers’ dumping costs. This happened either through negligence or by fraud, and it’s unclear at this point whether the existing haulers or the city, or some combination, bears responsibility.
It’s worth serious consideration.
That said, presented above is an excerpt of a transcript of the council’s Oct. 2 discussion on trash. This is the portion of the meeting in which the council decided not to approve the staff recommendation at the time (which would have given the entire contract to Fontana-based Burrtec, not Waste Management). As you read it, ask yourself two questions:
1) What the heck are they saying?
2) How do the two priorities compare at various points in the discussion: Hauler happiness vs. the best deal for taxpayers?
Enjoy!
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor.
