ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Trash, Part II: City Residents Need a Lawyer

No matter which companies are picked Thursday night to haul our trash for the next decade, the citizens of Santa Clarita are the winners.

The City Council, after much to-do, wisely put the trash contracts out to a competitive bid. The haulers made good offers in the ensuing free-market free-for-all, and then city staff officials twisted their arms so they’d give up even more.

Net, it’ll be a savings to the rate payers — you and me — of nearly $30 million over the life of the contracts. All because the City Council put the contracts to bid.

But when the dust settles, there will be some unfinished business that will need attending. Lest we forget, we rate payers have been overcharged many millions of dollars for trash pickup, dating back at least to 1996.

Through 2006, when the existing contracts expire, we will have overpaid at least $20 million, probably more, for trash pickup. We have a right to get that money back.

But we’ll need a class-action lawyer to get it for us, because the city government can’t do it. The city isn’t an injured party. It didn’t lose any tax dollars. Rather, we residents lost our private dollars to a private trash company when we paid the inflated rates — rates that were set by City Hall.

And that, I’m afraid, would make the city a defendant.

Here, in a nutshell, is how we’ve come to pay artificially inflated trash rates.

In 1994, as the city prepared to revise its contracts with the haulers — Blue Barrel, Santa Clarita Disposal and Atlas — the City Council hired a consulting firm, Hilton Farnkopf & Hobson, to figure out how much our trash rates should be.

HF&H used a formula to calculate the haulers’ actual operating costs and added in a reasonable 7-percent profit margin to determine our monthly trash rate.

One variable in the formula — not the only variable, but a big one — was the haulers’ dumping fee. That’s the amount the trash company has to pay the landfill company to dump your trash in the landfill.

When HF&H completed its study in 1995, it reported that the haulers were paying the landfill company $25.59 to dump a ton of trash in 1995, and it said they’d be paying $34.33 per ton in 1996.

Based on that formula, our residential trash rates for 1996-2006 were set at $22.13 per month.

Trouble is, the haulers never paid $34.33 to dump a ton of trash — and the city either (a) knew it; (b) should have known it; or (c) was lied to.

It makes a big difference. Option (a) spells duplicity; option (b) indicates negligence; option (c) lets the city off the hook — and puts the legal burden solely on the current haulers. So which is it?

There were two ways the city was supposed to learn the haulers’ individual dumping fees for HF&H’s calculations. One, the landfill company was supposed to send a letter to the city disclosing how much it charged them; two, city staff members were supposed to ask the haulers.

If the haulers told the city they’d be paying $34.33 in 1996, well, technically, that would be fraud. Blue Barrel had a contract with the landfill company to pay $25.59 per month. (At the time, Santa Clarita Disposal was owned by the Arklin brothers, who hauled trash to their own landfill in Palmdale — so they actually internalized their dumping fee.)

As for the disclosure letter the landfill company was supposed to send to the city:

“It appears we do not have this letter in the files. ... There is a lot of stuff that is missing,” the city’s trash coordinator told me 2 1/2 years ago when I broke the story.

Had HF&H used the true $25.59 dumping fee in its formula, the monthly cost to you and me would have been $1.67 less.

It gets weirder — and worse.

In the late 1990s, when several mergers and buyouts happened, Blue Barrel renegotiated its dumping fee. Now, instead of $25.59 per ton, it was paying only $11 to dump a ton of your trash in the landfill.

You and I were still paying monthly trash rates based on the erroneous dumping fee of $34.33 per ton.

Our trash rates should have gone down. The 1996 trash contracts had a provision where, if the haulers’ costs went way up or way down, our monthly trash rates would be adjusted accordingly.

But our rates didn’t go down. Mysteriously, right when Blue Barrel negotiated its $11-per-ton dumping fee — which also applied to Atlas and, soon thereafter, to Santa Clarita Disposal — the city rewrote its trash contracts to remove that provision. No longer were our household trash rates linked to the haulers’ costs.

Plug the $11-per-ton dumping fee into HF&H’s rate table, and you’d be paying at least $5 less per month for trash pickup.

That’s $60 per year, conservatively, through 2006. About $20 million citywide. Add in multi-family homes and you’re looking at more — a lot more.

That’s $20-million-plus that we’ve shelled out for — what? To pass along to nonprofit organizations? Guess again. Our trash haulers are nice to nonprofit organizations, but they’re not $20 million nice.

No matter how sweet a deal we get Thursday night for the future, we’re still owed millions of dollars that were swindled from us in the past — millions “extra” we paid, over and above the haulers’ costs, over and above a 7-percent profit margin.

If Santa Clarita Valley residents with leaky galvanized steel pipes can file class-action lawsuits and take Newhall Land and its subcontractors and suppliers for $41 million ... then there’s hope.

Leon Worden is The Signal’s city editor.

← Back to 2003

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:3751.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 959 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [city editor]
  • text:valley_names [4 distinct/10 mentions: Santa Clarita, Newhall, Newhall Land, City Council]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0