It’s a stalemate at the Newhall County Water District, and it may be one that only the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors can resolve.
The water agency’s governing board held a special meeting Thursday night to fill a vacant director’s spot, and was unable to agree on a replacement.
The spot on the historically divided board opened up when director Dick Unger resigned recently to move out of the district, leaving the decision-making body evenly divided on most issues — including the selection of his replacement.
Two of the directors, Barbara Dore and Randall Pfiester, were looking to fill the spot with former board member Valerie Thomas, while the other two directors, Lynne Plambeck and Joan Dunn, wanted to appoint one of the other candidates, Carolyn Shaffer, Thomas R. Gavin or Maria A. Gutzeit-Fahrenholz.
Early in the meeting, Plambeck asked if both candidate Mike Kotch and Thomas could be removed from consideration, since Plambeck and Dunn were backing Kotch and Dore and Pfiester were backing Thomas. She said she hoped it would allow new faces on the board, and hopefully move away from the factions that now exist on the publicly-voted board.
But Dore and Pfiester wouldn’t budge, with Dore later saying she was apprehensive about filling the position with one of the “unknowns,” meaning Gavin, Shaffer and Gutzeit-Fahrenholz, and saying Thomas had already served as a board member. Thomas served a four-year term from 1997 to 2001 when she was unseated by Dunn.
Dore argued in a statement that Thomas, who came in fourth for three seats in 2001, finished just 250 votes behind top vote-getter Dunn, and that Thomas won and Dunn lost in the Newhall and Castaic portions of the water district.
“The vote in Canyon Country was so lopsided that it actually pushed Dunn from fourth to first place,” Dore wrote.
“We really don’t know much about these (other candidates),” Dore said.
But Plambeck said the interview process conducted at another meeting Tuesday should have given all the directors a clear enough picture about the candidates.
“We all went through the interview process and we all asked questions,” Plambeck said.
She admitted that she could understand why Dore and Pfiester wouldn’t want to pick Kotch, as he is considered to be in the Plambeck-Dunn camp, but she said she couldn’t understand why there couldn’t be a compromise with one of the three “neutrals.”
“Why wouldn’t we be able to settle on one of these candidates,” Plambeck said.
If the board can’t make a decision on a replacement — the person would serve only until the next election in 2003, then go before the voters — the matter would either go to a special election or, if no action is taken by NCWD after 60 days, the county board of supervisors would make an appointment to fill the vacancy.
Most agree that a special election would be costly and unnecessary.
“Just our part from the last election was $30,000,” Dore said. “This time we would have to foot the entire bill.”
“It would be a serious waste of money,” she added.
At the meeting, all votes on candidates resulted in a 2-2 tie, although an NCWD official said the votes can be revisited.
Another special meeting is scheduled for July 23 to debate the matter — the day of the deadline for board action before the decision would be handed over to the supervisors.
