The Winner's Circle
I’m glad the BCS computers dropped the Trojans to No. 3.
Yes, I hated knowing I wouldn’t see them face Oklahoma for the so-called national title, but that disappointment gave way to sense of satisfaction that’s rooted much deeper than in the exploits of Southern California’s favorite football program.
I enjoyed seeing the BCS leave the No. 1 team in the country off its Sugar Bowl guest list because it affirmed the reason I refuse to become a fan of college football.
How can anyone put stock in a sport that relies on computers to determine its champion?
Can a computer stand on the sidelines and get a sense of a team’s emotional state? Does a computer take momentum into account? Can a hunk of wires and silicon chips consider the impact of injuries or illness, a coaching change or a team’s desire to exact revenge or earn a little respect?
What kind of results would a computer spit out if we asked it to predict Ali-Liston I, Villanova-Georgetown or U.S. Hockey-U.S.S.R?
No computer would have taken Douglas over Tyson or even the Dodgers over the A’s. I know, few humans would have either, but the wonderfully imaginative human mind will at least leave room for the possibility of the unexpected. A cold, unfeeling computer can’t.
I was inwardly pleased by the latest BCS debacle because it amounts to one giant step away from this ridiculous union of sports and computers.
The BCS officials may be standing by their man...er, machine. But I don’t believe their pet project will recover — that is, unless USC blows it on New Year’s Day. Michigan hasn’t seen this much support from the college football demigods since Bo Shembechler ran the show.
It won’t matter to me who wins the Rose Bowl. USC belongs in the Sugar Bowl regardless.
And college football deserves a stronger foundation. It should be allowed to stand tall on the stage of a national playoff, not teeter on the edge of a microchip.
* * *
In related news, Peter Wolfe, who runs one of the computer programs that helps the BCS make an annual mockery of college football, was recently asked to let his program rank Southern California’s high school football teams.
Westlake, which plays in Division IV, came out on top, mainly on the strength of its 14-0 season. I guess Wolfe’s computer wasn’t there the night Hart beat Westlake, but for a blown call on a Warriors two-point conversion.
I suppose that program didn’t see the picture The Signal ran the next day showing Westlake running back Tahj Mowry’s knee touching the turf before the ball broke the plane of the end zone during Hart’s 25-24 setback.
Hart finished seventh, behind two Division IV teams (Westlake and St. Bonaventure), a Division VI squad (Los Altos) and teams from Division V (Riverside North), III (SO Notre Dame) and one team from Division II.
It’s the other Division II team that irks me the most. The number six slot in Wolfe’s bogus poll goes to none other than Mission Viejo, which Hart dismantled 25-8 in last week’s CIF title game.
How can that be? Strength of schedule? No one disputes that the Indians played the stiffest competition in the Southland in 2003. Head-to-head competition? Obviously not. Wins and losses? Hmm...could it be?
The Diablos lost once, but by 17 points. The Indians lost three times by a grand total of 11. The Indians lost the first three games of the season. The Diablos lost the most important one.
Good thing for Hart computers don’t determine who wears the section crowns in high school sports. You actually have to earn it on the field.
How quaint.
Bob Dickson’s column appears ever Sunday in the Signal. He can be reached at [email protected].
