A federal judge threw out a civil rights lawsuit Wednesday that accused the Los Angeles County Sheriff?s Department of failing to enforce two separate child custody orders.
U.S. District Judge Christina A. Snyder dismissed the complaint against two individual deputies, but she left open the option for the plaintiffs, Michael Riportella and Michele Lansing, to refile their suit against Sheriff Leroy D. Baca and the county of Los Angeles.
The plaintiffs, represented by Saugus attorney Anthony D. Zinnanti, alleged that the Sheriff?s Department refused to enforce court orders to return their children to them.
Sheriff?s officials have acknowledged that the deputies didn?t carry out the court orders even though they were aware of them. SCV Sheriff?s Capt. Patti Minutello has said the department does not want to bring any more trauma to children. Whether deputies must physically remove kids should be left to the courts, she said.
The lawsuit claims that there had been such a court decision but it wasn?t carried out.
On Wednesday the judge ruled that the complaint against the individual deputies was inappropriate because the plaintiffs failed to show discrimination ? which they would need to do in order to bring a civil rights lawsuit against individual officers.
But the judge dismissed the portion of the suit against the county and the sheriff without prejudice, meaning it can be refiled.
?Basically the judge ruled to dismiss the civil rights lawsuit (without prejudice), giving me an opportunity to overcome what the judge sees as deficiencies in the complaint,? Zinnanti said.
He said he was thrilled with the ruling.
?The judge?s tentative ruling was to throw out the suit all together,? he said. ?In the court of oral argument, the judge was convinced that the plaintiffs deserved a second chance.?
Riportella was less enthusiastic.
?I was really hoping the deputies would be scolded for what they did,? said Riportella, who accused the deputies of intimidation by asking for his license and running a background check when he called on them to enforce a court order.
?They made me feel like I was the one who did something wrong. I was just a dad who wanted to get my kids back.?
Lansing, whose ex-husband refused to return her 15-year-old child after 34 days, said she was saddened by the experience.
?The Sheriff?s Department is not accountable for anything,? she said. ?There is no one I can turn to, to protect my rights and the rights of my children.?
Zinnanti said if the lawsuit is thrown out a second time, an appeal would be inevitable.
?If we don?t prevail, I will seek review before the U.S. Supreme Court,? he said. ?I?m creating the basis for a new law, with respect to the question of whether there is an affirmative duty to enforce the law.?
Janine S. McMillion, the attorney representing the Sheriff?s Department in the case, could not be reached for comment.
