A new board majority of the Newhall County water District is considering a resolution that would effectively declare the valley's water supply insufficient for any new construction within the agency's boundaries.
On a 4-1 vote Thursday evening, the NCWD board delayed for two weeks its decision on the resolution, which states that the agency "has no confidence in" figures presented in the valley's Urban water Management Plan.
Board member Barbara Dore cast the dissenting vote.
NCWD, which provides water to Newhall, Castaic, and the Pinetree section of Canyon Country, had helped craft and endorse the water plan in 2000.
The water plan forecasts water supply and demand from existing residents and new development.
The board's new resolution would lower the estimation of current water supplies, the net effect being that NCWD is actually providing more water today than figures show it has.
After nearly two hours of heated public testimony, representatives from local school districts and members of the development community urged board members to delay approving the resolution, citing the need for further review of the document — a document the majority of the speakers said was received at the last minute.
Board president Lynne Plambeck was adamant in saying figures included in the report have been around for 20 years and did not feel the need to delay the approval.
Rory Livingston, assistant superintendent of the William S. Hart Union High School District, said adoption of the report may interfere in the district's current plans for construction of desperately needed schools.
The Hart District is planning to build a high school in the NorthLake community of Castaic, but officials indicated there would be difficulty in issuing water permits for the school if the resolution were adopted.
Ray Pearl, executive director of the Building Industry Association, said developers would be severely impacted if the resolution is approved.
Pearl urged NCWD to delay the item for at least 90 days for the opportunity to review and study the document.
"To act otherwise would be irresponsible," he said.
Several residents of the Vasquez Canyon area, who are supplied by dwindling private wells and have been requesting service from NCWD for years, also voiced opposition to the resolution, fearing more delays connecting to the district's service area.
Mark Gates, developer of the Gate/King Industrial Park at Needham Ranch, which was recently approved by the Santa Clarita City Council, engaged in a pointed exchange with Plambeck.
Gates queried Plambeck as to whether a hypothetical business owner who wanted to improve his property would be able to get a "will-serve letter" from the agency.
water agencies must issue "will-serve" letters, indicating the agency will provide water before construction can commence.
Plambeck admitted it would be very difficult for the district to issue such letters if the resolution is approved.
Gates chided Plambeck for failing to provide adequate time for public input.
"Lynne, you of all people, you are the one who always wants people (to have) the opportunity to be heard," said Gates, who termed the resolution Draconian. "I would like to be given the same rights that you always insisted upon us."
Gates said before the meeting, the (Industrial Park's) environmental impact report was recently certified, which would have been the next step in annexing into NCWD's service area.
Leon Worden, a member of the city's Newhall Redevelopment Committee, asked the board to delay its decision for 90 days.
"If the resolution prevents the agency from issuing will-serve letters, I would be very scared," Worden said. "It could kill redevelopment in downtown Newhall."
NCWD Manager Ken Petersen said before the meeting he was not sure just what impact the resolution will have on future growth.
"The board has not yet given me direction," Petersen said. "I can surmise that future requests for connection to the district's service area will require additional analysis."
As of Thursday afternoon, CLWA President Peter Kavounas said he had not seen the resolution but was aware of it.
Kavounas said he stands by the water plan, which is currently being challenged by the Friends of the Santa Clara River and the Sierra Club. The lawsuit accuses CLWA of overstating groundwater supplies because of perchlorate contamination in the Saugus Aquifer; overstating the reliability of imported water from northern California; and believes there was insufficient public notification of the legal documents.
"I am very confident and comfortable with the numbers the agency has produced," Kavounas said before the meeting. "Lynne Plambeck and the all environmentalists have challenged us in the past and lost. The numbers are good and we stand by them."
Board member Randall Pfiester disapproved of the resolution, which he said could destroy the district.
"I don't need 30 days, I don't need 90 days (to review the resolution)," he said. "The best thing for us to do with the resolution is to put it in the shredder."
However, Pfiester later voted in favor of the delay because, he said, "That's the best that we're going to get."
