In a scene reminiscent of last year?s larger ?Save Old Glory? rallies, a small group of environmental activists gathered outside the fenced-in ancient oak tree to ask developers to stop the relocation process slated for later this month.
Terry Tamminen, secretary of the state?s Environmental Protection Agency, spoke to more than 25 children and Old Glory supporters Saturday after examining the tree and meeting with representatives of John Laing Homes. The valley oak tree, estimated by arborists at 400 years old, lives at the center of a road widening project within the housing development.
Tamminen said his visit was unofficial because the EPA has no jurisdiction over local property matters. Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger appointed Tamminen to his cabinet last November to oversee six EPA departments including strategic planning and pollution prevention.
A founder of the Santa Monica BayKeeper and former executive director of Environment Now in Santa Monica, Tamminen said the argument over the oak tree is a symptom of the lack of creative planning that could have prevented the controversy.
?I?m not sure what the solution is,? Tamminen said. ?The planning that was needed to go on here could have avoided this 10 years ago. We should not have this conversation 10 years from now.?
Tamminen was impressed with the long-term community support for Old Glory that started on Oct. 1, 2002 when environmental educator John Quigley scaled the 70-foot tree to prevent it from being cut down. The rally was held on the one year anniversary of the end Quigley?s 71-day residency.
Eight children from Wiley Canyon Elementary School, led by 12-year-old Cassie Maier, chanted ?Arnold Please Save The Tree,? and held hand-made red stop signs that spelled out their chant in the hopes their message will reach the governor. The children will transfer to the new Pico Canyon Elementary School when it opens.
?The governor has received lots of calls, e-mails, and letters,? Tamminen said. ?I will report back to him if he asks.?
Laing Homes officials said a team of arborists and landscape architects are confident the oak tree will survive the relocation to a 18-acre oak tree preserve about a quarter mile east of its present site on Pico Canyon Road. A five-year maintenance program is planned to start once the relocation process is completed.
Bill Rattazzi, Laing Homes president, said the care Old Glory has received since the transplant process began in February 2003 has enhanced the tree?s overall health.
?While we can?t predict the future, it has a very good opportunity to grow and flourish,? Rattazzi said.
However, Andy Lipkis, founder of the Treepeople organization, said the roots have been cut and the damage could be irreversible unless the giant planter box is removed and the tree is allowed to remain in its original habitat.
?It?s not going to make a difference in it?s ultimate survival,? Lipkis said.
