One of the long-standing complaints local environmentalists and anti-growth activists have had is that pro-growth politicians, when in power, impose their will with little regard for opposing views.
Considering that, it was ironic this week to see a new majority on the Newhall County Water District board attempt to do that very thing.
The new board majority quietly placed a resolution on the board agenda that would potentially shut down any future development within the district’s boundaries.
Reserving judgment on the actual water debate for now, one immediate conclusion that can be drawn is that the new board majority’s process is flawed. They made no plans for a public review and input process, instead slipping a resolution onto the agenda that could dramatically alter the future growth — or non-growth — of the Santa Clarita Valley.
Further, the resolution could have a significant amount of collateral damage, affecting things like downtown Newhall redevelopment and some much-needed new schools.
What’s interesting about this particular debate is that both sides have a point.
It’s our belief that water districts, like the Newhall County Water District, should not be used as growth management tools. They should neither intentionally hamper growth, nor should their power and authority be abused in order to promote growth at the expense of existing residents’ future well-being.
Both sides of the local growth debate pay lip service to agreeing with that position. But they both abuse it.
Anyone want to be brutally honest? Pro-growth forces in this town try to manipulate and control the local water agencies in order to facilitate growth, sometimes with disregard for the very real fact that water in the SCV is a painfully finite supply.
And on the other side, anti-growth forces obviously view water as a tool to limit growth — perhaps by exaggerating the nature of any real or imagined water availability crisis.
As with many such political debates, the truth is probably somewhere in the middle — and it’s a moving target, because predicting future water availability is a complex, inexact business.
Finding the reasonable “middle ground” is contingent upon vigorous, public debate. If that’s what the new NCWD board majority really wants, they’ll back off on their rush to rescind the water district’s backing of the valley’s Urban Water Management Plan.
Is that plan flawed? Perhaps. But if the NCWD board members are smart, they’ll lay out a plan for a thorough public review and comment process before taking any action. That means the board’s decision on Thursday to delay the ruling until Jan. 29 won’t be sufficient. More time is warranted.
Slam-dunk declarations that could bring development to a screeching halt don’t exactly send a message of good faith. If the new NCWD board majority wants to be seen as anything other than anti-growth zealots, a more methodical, careful approach is warranted.
