The Newhall County Water Board dropped a bombshell on the Santa Clarita Valley on Thursday night.
The three slow-growth members who control the five-person board — Lynne Plambeck, Maria Gutzeit and Joan Dunn — came within a hair’s breath of approving a resolution that could turn off the agency’s spigot for any new development.
Will it mean no new high school in NorthLake? No community center and no more redevelopment in Newhall? No new housing tracts or shopping centers in Castaic? No new business park on the Needham Ranch?
It could mean all of those things and more. Nobody knows for sure — not the various government agencies, and not the water board.
Instead of approving the resolution, the board delayed its decision until Jan. 29 to give the public some time to react. In my opinion that’s not enough time for the city, the school districts, the town councils and interested individuals to digest the information and contemplate its sweeping consequences.
But that’s neither here nor there. If the board majority’s deportment Thursday night is an indicator, approval of the resolution in some form is inevitable.
Is this political suicide for the three board members, or is it just what the voters want? Anyone who follows water issues in our valley should have seen this coming. Voters in the Newhall County Water District gave the slow growth candidates a wide margin of victory on Nov. 4, and “honest reporting of water supplies” was their chief doctrine.
What was never fully explained during the election, though, were the ramifications of taking those buzz words to the extreme.
Let me back up by saying I can empathize with Lynne Plambeck. For years she has been virtually a lone wolf, crying that the sky is falling, that we don’t have enough water to sustain the current pace of growth in our valley.
When she has said the water agencies are in the pockets of big developers she has been ridiculed. When she has said they’ve cooked the books on water she has been ignored.
Is she right? Is the sky falling? Have the valley’s water agencies been draining our shallow underground water supply, pumping beyond its “safe yield” for the last decade?
Water agencies and developers have spent tens if not hundreds of thousands of dollars fighting her in court over the years, producing voluminous documentation in their efforts to prove her wrong.
But now the shoe is on the other foot. Now she’s in charge. The Nov. 4 election put her in the majority, and her allies made her board president.
One of those allies is Maria Gutzeit. A chemical engineer with an environmental compliance consulting business, she was the principal author of the resolution that would implement the new majority’s position on groundwater management.
Like Plambeck, she’s no dummy. Unlike Plambeck, she’s a newcomer to local politics and hasn’t exhibited the same “my way or the highway” approach that tends to make Plambeck her own worst enemy.
One thing that was clear Thursday night was that the three-member majority isn’t accustomed to being in charge. It’s as if they can’t believe it. Members of the public who testified on the resolution — school district representatives, developers, homeowners — were dispatched so brusquely that it seemed Plambeck was avenging all the times she was in their position, testifying before their boards, on their development projects, only to be rebuffed just as abruptly.
Revenge is sweet, but two wrongs don’t make a right when you’re considering a policy that would have colossal — and unforeseen — impacts.
Let’s say, for argument’s sake, that Plambeck’s numbers are the right numbers and, as she says, delaying the adoption of the resolution won’t change the numbers. Fine. The issue is what you do with those numbers — not the “whereas-es,” but the “therefore be it resolved-s.”
For several years, the water agencies have done one thing with the numbers (Plambeck says “ignored them”) and have provided water for new development. Now the board would do a 180 with those numbers and potentially disallow new hookups — be it for a school, a house or a civic building, no one knows.
If the new majority is so sure it’s right, then it shouldn’t be afraid to give the rate payers, the school districts, the city, and yes, even the developers, a reasonable opportunity to understand the implications and offer their opinions on how the agency should proceed.
Leon Worden is The Signal’s city editor.
