The Great Water War of 2004 is only a week old, and already there have been missteps on both sides.
In one corner is the new slow-growth majority on the Newhall County Water District board, which fired the opening salvo a week ago with a resolution that would overturn the agency’s previous position on water management. The resolution is based on the new majority’s opinion that, in a nutshell, the water agencies have misrepresented water availability to accommodate big developers.
In the other corner are the developers, the other water purveyors and now, the generally pro-growth Santa Clarita City Council, which approved its own resolution Tuesday, attacking the water board’s yet-unadopted resolution.
As we’ve noted, the water board majority was too hasty in trying to enforce its opinion without giving the public ample time to study the implications of a decision that could conceivably put new homes, civic buildings and even schools on hold.
But if the water board ’s three-week delay isn’t long enough, the council went them one better. Without any advance warning, the council decided the new water board majority is wrong.
It would be one thing if the council simply asked the water board for more time. Instead, the council decided it opposes the water board’s resolution, and even decided what laws would need to be followed when the water board makes its decision (not that the council has any say in the matter).
There are two problems. First, the council didn’t give the public the same courtesy it’s asking of the water board — namely, time to weigh in before deciding if the water board’s resolution should be adopted. Second, the council may be wrong about the particulars.
The water board, in its resolution, declares it no longer has confidence in the Urban Water Management Plan, which says more water is available than the new majority thinks. The resolution also voices their opposition to pumping the valley’s underground aquifer beyond safe levels, as determined by the new majority.
In its resolution, the City Council states, “Any legally valid changes and/or modifications of Urban Water Management Plan 2000 must be consistent with the procedures outlined in the Urban Water Management Planning Act;” and, “Any changes or modifications of the Urban Water Management Plan ... must contain specific adherence to ... the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).”
Trouble is, the jury’s out as to whether the water board’s resolution would constitute an amendment, as defined by law, to the valley’s Urban Water Management Plan. It might not, in which case it wouldn’t need to comply with the Urban Water Management Planning Act.
And, CEQA doesn’t apply to Urban Water Management Plans.
The irony is, some of the very people who now control the water board sued the Castaic Lake Water Agency when it adopted the Urban Water Management Plan. They tried, and failed, to convince a judge that the Urban Water Management Plan should be subject to CEQA.
Now the tables are turned. Now CLWA thinks the NCWD board’s resolution may be subject to CEQA.
Maybe it is, maybe it isn’t. If the resolution does not constitute an amendment, as defined, to the Urban Water Management Plan, then it might fall under CEQA. Nobody really knows, including the City Council.
We’d like to see the Great Water War of 2004 fizzle into a comprehensive, if tedious, discussion of just how much water is available for current residents and growth. So far, neither side is accommodating it.
