ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Water Debate Could Stall Development

One side says it?s about quality-of-life issues, such as the assurance that safe water flows out when you turn on your tap.

The other side says it?s about quality-of-life issues, such as adequate schools and community centers ? the ability to meet the needs of a growing community.

Both sides say the facts support them.

But no one will dispute the skirmish touched off by Newhall County Water District board members earlier this month when they took up a resolution declaring less water is available in the Santa Clarita Valley than previously thought.

A declaration of war might have been as well received.

The water district, one of four retailers that serve the Santa Clarita Valley, has booked Hart Hall at William S. Hart Park for a public hearing Thursday night in anticipation of an uproar over its resolution. The document, which board members considered earlier this month but tabled, challenges an Urban Water Management Plan that water agencies ? including the NCWD?s board at the time ? signed off on in 2000.

The implications are staggering, officials say. And some say the issue isn?t really about water at all, but a political move by a longtime group of anti-growth environmentalists to slow or halt development in the Santa Clarita Valley.

City officials say the resolution could stall current and end future construction, and that it may be illegal. A school official says it could thwart district expansion, and a fellow water purveyor says it?s based on inaccurate information.

?This is sort of a bagful of nails that was thrown in the roadway,? said Rory Livingston, assistant superintendent for the William S. Hart Union High School District. ?We have to go down that roadway? to complete new school construction, he said.

?Their agenda is to prove that there is no water for anyone else who doesn?t already live here,? said Barbara Dore, a member of the NCWD board who opposes the resolution. ?And by proving that, no planning agencies that are involved in this area will be able to approve any development,? added Dore, a member of the Castaic Lake Water Agency board.

?We don?t have the power to halt development in this valley,? Newhall County board President Lynne Plambeck responded. ?We have the responsibility to ensure that water is properly reported.?

?There?s a bunch of water in (the Urban Water Management Plan) that doesn?t really exist,? Plambeck said. ?What we?re trying to do is plan for a dry year. If we have a drought, and we have it soon ... we?re going to have a lot of trouble supplying people.?

Plambeck, Joan Dunn and Maria Gutzeit became the water board?s majority in November, elected in part on a promise to honestly assess water supplies, she said. Plambeck is a longtime environmental activist involved in the groups Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment and Friends of the Santa Clara River.

While she denied a secret agenda to halt Santa Clarita Valley development, Plambeck was critical of the rapid rate at which new homes go up.

?Ten-thousand single-family homes (have been) approved, (are) coming online,? she said. ?It?s like nobody?s looking forward.?

?I think the vehemence (over the proposed resolution) comes from the development communty having misrepresented this for so many years now,? Plambeck added. ?The only reason that I can see for this kind of reaction is that they know darn well that we?re telling the truth and they are very worried about it. And it?s all developer driven.?

Solid figures on water availability became essential for new development on Jan. 1, 2002, when state water codes were revised, said David Orosco, spokesman for state Sen. Pete Knight, R-Lancaster.

Any proposal for a development of 500 or more homes must include an assessment of water availability for the development, along with information on where that water would come from, Orosco said. The 2000 Urban Water Management Plan provided the assurance that water retailers relied upon as they issued commitments, called ?will-serve letters,? that said they would provide water for new developments.

The NCWD resolution, if passed, would challenge the water plan on three fronts: It says the plan counts polluted water as available; it says the plan calls for too much groundwater pumping; and it says the plan relies on water that is only potentially available. It proposes removing these alleged questionable resources from the list of available water.

The difference between NCWD?s water figures and those in the approved 2000 plan are substantial. NCWD says confirmed water supplies amount to a little more than 64,000 acre-feet per year. The Urban Water Management Plan?s figures range from 103,200 acre-feet per year to 279,700 acre-feet per year, depending on weather conditions.

One acre-foot is 325,851 gallons; it?s enough to serve two average households for a year.

City officials are fretting that projects such as the proposed Santa Clarita Community Center in downtown Newhall could be left high and dry if the resolution passes.

Development decisions made by the City Council and Planning Commission ?were predicated on the knowledge that we had received from NCWD that there would be water available,? said Mike Murphy, intergovernmental relations director for the city of Santa Clarita. ?Now there seems to be concern about whether not there will be an adequate supply.?

?On the one hand, we have the Castaic Lake Water Agency believing that there is an adequate water supply throughout the community,? Murphy said. ?And then we have the NCWD as one of the local retailers saying, ?No, we do not believe that we have enough water for our service area.? And so what we?re getting here is a conflicting message.?

Murphy said the city wants its staff members to sit down with NCWD staffers and figure out the implications of the resolution. The NCWD resolution offers to share information with other agencies, and a revision dated Wednesday concedes that the board?s proposed stand could be revised ?on a case-by-case basis or as new facts, data or studies justify.?

The Castaic Lake Water Agency is a wholesaler that provides state water from Northern California to local retailers: NCWD, Valencia Water Co., Santa Clarita Water Division, which is owned by CLWA, and Los Angeles County Waterworks District 36. Generally, the water sold by retailers is about a 50-50 mix of state and well water, although percentages can vary depending on the retailer, on the weather and on some other factors.

In its resolution opposing NCWD?s proposed resolution, the city of Santa Clarita suggested Newhall County would be violating the California Environmental Quality Act if it passed the resolution. Mayor Bob Kellar also suggested NCWD wasn?t following public disclosure laws.

The city?s resolution passed unanimously, as did a Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce resolution that says the ?practical effect? of NCWD?s resolution would be ?the refusal by NCWD to issue any further can- and will-serve letters within its district boundaries.?

Plambeck said NCWD would do all it could to continue serving its customers, including new customers to its area.

Livingston of William S. Hart Union High School District said the resolution could stymie a new high school and other schools in Castaic. NCWD serves sections of Newhall, Canyon Country, and Castaic.

New school sites depend upon developers? willingness to sell those sites to the districts, Livingston said. If the North Lake development is halted due to lack of water, he said, the developer won?t sell the site to the district.

?There goes Castaic High School,? he said. A proposed junior high and two elementary sites also could be affected, he said. Castaic Union School District is due to take up NCWD?s proposed resolution at a special meeting of the district?s governing board Monday morning.

?To get schools built is such a long, drawn-out process to begin with,? Livingston said. ?You can?t just look at the school sites,? he said, but also ?how they relate to the community, how different things are being financed. There?s a lot of players.?

Water supplies for new schools would not be a problem if the number of students remained the same, Plambeck said. Shifting the same students from elementary to junior high to high school would not change their water consumption.

She questioned how the Hart district could oppose NCWD?s plan to remove contaminated water from the list of available supplies. ?How (can) school districts, of all people, want to leave water that?s polluted in the available water column??

?All we have the ability to do is to accurately report our water supplies,? she said of the water district. ?How they fund the schools is not our problem.?

?There?re other ways to fund schools. Our business is making sure the community has a water supply that they can rely on,? Plambeck said.

Henry Schultz, a Sierra Club official and candidate for City Council, said ?there?s plenty of water to supply schools.?

Pro-development forces ?go out and try to use schools and children and everything else as hostages,? he said.

Valencia Water Co. President Robert DiPrimio, a member of the Castaic Lake Water Agency board, said water supplies are more objectively measurable than the issue suggests.

?My problem with the current water debate is that there?s a perception that there hasn?t been a neutral third party review of our water supply-and-demand situation,? DiPrimio said. ?That?s just not the case. The PUC (Public Utilities Commission) did that and completely rejected the (environmentalists?) argument.?

In November 2001, the PUC upheld a Valencia Water Co. water management program that formed the basis for the Urban Water Management Plan, Di Primio said. The PUC ordered Valencia Water to update its water plan in 1999 when it sought to expand its service area.

The plan was challenged by the Sierra Club, Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment, Friends of the Santa Clara River and Ventura County. The PUC concluded that Valencia Water?s plan was sound for current and future needs, that the firm did not propose overpumping the aquifers, and that drought-contingency plans were ?reasonable.?

?What we have here is a group of individuals who want to believe their own information,? DiPrimio said of the NCWD majority. ?(There?s) no scientific basis to hang their hats on other than that?s what they want to believe.?

Plambeck noted that Valencia Water is a division of Newhall Land and Farming, suggesting a pro-development conflict of interest on the water agency?s part. The same environmental groups that opposed Valencia?s water management program in 1999 opposed its sale to Lennar Corp./LNR Property Corp. as part of the buyout of Newhall Land. The PUC, on a 4-1 vote, upheld that sale last week.

If the water board approves its proposed resolution, the impact is likely to be felt in courts and campaigning, at least.

?We?re talking lawsuit central,? said Dore, one of two NCWD board members likely to vote against the resolution.

?Clearly this is a politically motivated effort by the majority of the (water) board,? said City Councilman Cameron Smyth.

Smyth and Mayor Bob Kellar face the Sierra Club?s Schultz in the upcoming April city election. And Schultz says he wholeheartedly supports the NCWD board.

?As a candidate, I?m taking the stance taken by the water district,? Schultz said Saturday. ?All the numbers that I see that are real numbers show that the water isn?t there.?

While they seem oceans apart on the issue of current water availability, Schultz and one of the resolution?s opponents agree that a day of reckoning over water may be coming.

Despite her vehement opposition to the NCWD resolution, Dore admits, ?Very possibly there will come a time in the future when there are really serious issues over how many more people we can serve.? About 80 percent of the state?s water goes to agricultural uses, yet the population continues to grow, she said.

?People come from all 49 other states; we can?t keep them out,? she said. ?The water purveyors are not estimating what the future population will be. We are taking other people?s estimates.?

?We need to see more planning,? said Schultz. ?We?re going to end up with no water.

?People think it?s going to be there forever, but it?s not.?

← Back to 2004

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:4034.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 2,019 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • text:valley_names [15 distinct/57 mentions: Santa Clarita, Valencia, Newhall, Canyon Country, Hart district, William S. Hart, Castaic High, Newhall Land]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [Lila Campuzano]
  • text:valley_elected_official “Cameron Smyth”, “Smyth”, “Knight, R-”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0