Some toting sleepy, fussy, or silent, big-eyed children, more than 100 people crammed City Council chambers Tuesday night to protest last week?s closure of a popular Valencia dance studio.
It was standing room only in the 160-capacity council chambers as parents, students, and teachers at Dance Studio 84 took the podium and called for the studio to be reopened.
?It means so much to us. It?s our passion; it?s our home,? student Kelly Russo tearfully told council members. ?If Dance Studio 84 is closed entirely, something inside us will die.?
?Carla?s not making a killing out there,? said parent Robert Waldau. ?When you make business expensive, business leaves.?
The studio, owned by Carla Hunt-Smallwood, was closed Thursday night by Los Angeles County fire inspectors. Both city and Fire Department officials said the studio near Valencia High School was in violation of numerous safety codes.
Some of those who spoke Tuesday night accused council members of being indifferent to the needs of the city?s youth, being anti-business, or being mindless bureaucrats enforcing petty rules.
But council members Frank Ferry and Laurene Weste challenged their statements, noting the issue was one of safety.
Ferry, himself near tears, said going to funerals of young people who died due to negligence or recklessness is the hardest part of his job.
Weste said the city staff could help expedite the studio?s reopening, but the code violations must be addressed.
?Not one of us wants to be at a funeral for your child and have to look at you and grieve with you, knowing that there was something we could have done,? she told parents in the audience.
The studio has been operating without Fire Department permits or a city certificate of occupancy for more than a year. Hunt-Smallwood was given notice of required upgrades in October 2002 but has made little progress in improving the studio, said Vince Bertoni, the city?s interim planning director.
?I think the staff bent over backward? to help her, said Councilman Cameron Smyth.
Hunt-Smallwood told council members that at least part of the problem was a ?misunderstanding regarding the amount of space required for one dancing child.?
She said she moved to the Valencia facility because it was bigger, and she believed safer, than her previous location.
?We have started over? on the required improvements with a new architect, she said, thanking the council for an extension of her minor use permit, which allows her business to continue its building permit applications.
In a statement posted to the dance studio?s Web site, she said the city has suggested that she ?ignored this situation, ignored phone calls.?
?I did not ignore this situation, and as far as I know, all correspondence was responded to. Did I feel like they wanted to help to make this work for me? No,? Hunt-Smallwood said. ?Could I have done more to avoid the time running out? Probably, but I thought we were on track.?
City officials have been bombarded with protesting e-mail and had staff and fire officials on hand Tuesday evening to respond to accusations.
Among documents they released was a Jan. 22 official Fire Department inspection report on the studio at 27889 N. Smyth Drive. It listed violations for:
? Exit doors did not swing outward and did not include ?panic hardware? that would allow them to be easily opened in an emergency.
? Exits from the second floor and main exercise floor were blocked by ?cabinets, chairs, equipment, and miscellaneous construction supplies.?
? The second floor was overcrowded.
? Emergency lighting and emergency exit signs were missing or inadequate.
Some protesters suggested that the city modify occupancy limits for dance and karate studios. But city building official Ruben Barrera said state law dictates that studios employ the same ?occupant load factor? that?s used for classrooms. Changing the law on the local level is not an option, he said.
Hunt-Smallwood said Dance Studio 84 serves about 700 students and has been in business in Santa Clarita for 18 years.
The studio was first opened in 1976 by Reena Newhall under the name Reena?s Dance Studio. In 1982 Newhall sold the facility to a dance studio chain, from which Hunt-Smallwood later bought it.
